Sign up for our newsletter

The Payments That Unite Us

Mike Antonucci, Intercepts

The teachers’ unions are getting very jazzed about their national day of action on Monday. Joy Resmovits of the Huffington Post reports the American Federation of Teachers is laying out $1.2 million on the campaign:

“The unions are calling the movement a groundswell of organic support against the usurping of public schools by “corporate interests” that want to make a “market-based system of schooling” involving high-stakes testing and attacks on collective bargaining. An AFT one-pager obtained by HuffPostlists the day’s purpose as “to begin to create a national echo chamber for our vision and narrative.”

It’s organic, all right, if you define it as something that requires fertilizer to grow. I took a good look at the list of 167 endorsers of “The Principles That Unite Us” and found 52 unions. That still leaves a good group of community organizations and advocacy groups, which for curiosity sake I cross-referenced with my lists of advocacy groups that received payments from NEA and AFT national headquartersduring the 2011-12 fiscal year.

Surprise! Seventeen were recipients of AFT money that year, and four received NEA money. A quick scan of AFT’s 2012-13 disclosure report turned up an additional seven groups that cashed AFT checks. That doesn’t include groups on the endorsers’ list like FairTest who have received union contributions in the past, but not for the last two years. Nor does it include groups that may have received funds from AFT or NEA state and local affiliates.

So as you listen to the laments at Monday’s rallies, consider them just AFT’s beneficiaries singing for their supper.

Teachers Unions Face Moment of Truth

Stephanie Simon, Politico

It’s designed to be an impressive show of force: Thousands of unionized teachers plan to rally Monday in cities from New York to San Francisco to “reclaim the promise of public education.”

Behind the scenes, however, teachers unions are facing tumultuous times. Long among the wealthiest and most powerful interest groups in American politics, the unions are grappling with financial, legal and public-relations challenges as they fight to retain their clout and build alliances with a public increasingly skeptical of big labor.

“I do think it’s a moment of truth,” said Lance Alldrin, a veteran high-school teacher in Corning, Calif., who has split from his longtime union after serving for a decade as the local president.

The National Education Association has lost 230,000 members, or 7 percent, since 2009, and it’s projecting another decline this year, which will likely drop it below 3 million members. Among the culprits: teacher layoffs, the rise of non-unionized charter schools and new laws in states such as Wisconsin and Michigan freeing teachers to opt out of the union.

The American Federation of Teachers has been able to grow slightly and now represents 1.5 million workers — but because many new members are retirees or part-timers who pay lower dues, union revenue actually fell last year, by nearly $6 million, federal records show.

Moreover, the membership of the NEA and AFT overlaps considerably; some 663,000 workers show up on both rolls because their locals maintain dual affiliations. That double counting inflates perceptions of the teacher lobby’s combined strength. Total union membership isn’t 4.5 million — it’s 3.8 million.

The unions and their affiliates still control huge resources. They collectively bring in more than $2 billion a year, most of it from member dues. Yet there are signs of financial strain. The NEA has cut spending by 12 percent in the last two years, in part by reducing its staff. And after years of posting surpluses, the AFT has been running deficits. It wrapped up the most recent fiscal year owing $3.7 million on its line of credit, up from $916,000 the previous year, according to records filed with the U.S. Department of Labor. (AFT officials point out that’s still just a fraction of the union’s $155 million general fund budget.)

The unions also face threats to their public image.

Former U.S. Solicitor General Theodore Olson expects to go to trial in California next month with an audacious lawsuit that aims to overturn teacher job protections, such as tenure, that unions helped muscle into state law.

His work in the courtroom will be paired with a broad PR campaign painting the teachers unions as obstructionists who protect their members at all costs.

Olson has gathered hair-raising stories about a small number of teachers who sexually harassed students, refused to plan lessons, appeared on campus under the influence, yet held onto their jobs for years because of union-backed job protections. Exhibit A: The Los Angeles Unified School District, which spent a decade and $3.5 million trying to dismiss seven teachers for poor performance — and only succeeded in ousting four. Rather than attempting to fire Mark Berndt, a veteran teacher who pleaded guilty last month to lewd acts with his students, the district paid him $40,000 to resign.

Union leaders say that Olson is distorting the picture by focusing on a few bad apples. “Parents will see through that,” NEA President Dennis Van Roekel said.

But Olson says he intends to use tactics borrowed from his successful fight to overturn California’s ban on same-sex marriage – plus funding from Silicon Valley entrepreneur David Welch – to make sure he wins not just in the legal arena, but “in the court of public opinion.”

More bad press for unions looms on the East Coast, where former CNN anchor Campbell Brown has financed TV ads and a relentless social media campaign accusing the unions of protecting New York City teachers who sexually harass students. She’s got some vivid, cringe-inducing examples – and she’s planning to kick the campaign into high gear this winter.

Union leaders say they don’t protect bad teachers, just seek to ensure due process. And they brush off the negative publicity as a political ploy that won’t gain traction. The American public, they say, is much more interested in talking about scrapping high-stakes testing, broadening the curriculum, reducing class sizes and spreading resources equitably — all issues that unions have championed.

(Also on POLITICO: Little-known higher ed nominees raise eyebrows)

In the struggle for “hearts and minds,” unions are winning, AFT President Randi Weingarten said.

It’s not clear, however, that those alliances are deep or durable: Support for labor unions in general has fallen steadily, dipping below 50 percent for the first time in 2012 before rebounding slightly this year, Gallup polls find. Only 32 percent of Americans expressed a positive view of teachers unions (and another 25 percent were neutral) in a poll last year by the journal Education Next.

To be sure, unions still have the funding and the foot soldiers to be power players. The NEA and AFT spent more than $40 million last year on federal lobbying and electoral politics, according to the Center for Responsive Politics, plus tens of millions more in the states. And they can still splurge when it’s important to them: The AFT bought $1.2 million worth of TV, radio and print advertising this weekend to promote the National Day of Action.

But labor analysts say it’s clearly a new environment for teachers unions. “They’re much more on the defensive now,” said Katharine Strunk, an education professor who studies labor at the University of Southern California.

“This is a very, very challenging time for unions,” said John Logan, a professor of labor history at San Francisco State University.

Among the challenges: Dissent from within.

 

Daily Headlines for December 9, 2013

Click here for Newswire, the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else – spiced with a dash of irreverence – from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

NATIONAL COVERAGE

The Auditor: Christie, education leader go from friendly to foes again
Column, Star-ledger, NJ, December 8, 2013
Just 13 months ago, Gov. Chris Christie and Randi Weingarten, national president of the American Federation of Teachers, were all smiles, appearing together on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe.”

Who Says Math Has to Be Boring?
Editorial, New York Times, NY, December 8, 2013
American students are bored by math, science and engineering. They buy smartphones and tablets by the millions but don’t pursue the skills necessary to build them. Engineers and physicists are often portrayed as clueless geeks on television, and despite the high pay and the importance of such jobs to the country’s future, the vast majority of high school graduates don’t want to go after them.

STATE COVERAGE

ARIZONA

Huppenthal wants state Supreme Court to maintain voucher program
East Valley Tribune, AZ, December 8, 2013
Saying it’s really a legal contract between the state and parents, Superintendent of Schools John Huppenthal is urging the Arizona Supreme Court to uphold the legality of what amounts to a voucher program for students.

More money for charter schools should mean higher expectations
Column, Arizona Star, AZ, December 8, 2013
For four years, Arizona charter schools have been arguing in court that they get a raw deal from the Legislature.

CALIFORNIA

Choice benefits students
Letter, The Reporter, CA, December 8, 2013
It is not surprising that a recently published column (“School choice isn’t the biggest need,” Dec. 3) by a past teachers union leader downplays the courageous action taken by Vacaville Unified School District trustees at their Nov. 21 meeting.

School librarian helps students struggling with reading
Los Angeles Times, CA, December 7, 2013
Program aims to help young children, most with Spanish-speaking parents, whose reading scores aren’t where they should be.

CONNECTICUT

Suspensions down, but imbalance persists
Connecticut Post, CT, December 8, 2013
Statewide school suspension rates were down for the fifth straight year in 2012-13, but a disturbing pattern that seems to target boys, minority students and charter school students remains.

FLORIDA

Florida students ‘happy’ at school despite lagging PISA scores
Miami Herald, FL, December 7, 2013
Florida’s students lag behind most of the developed world when it comes to math and science, but at least they’re generally “happy” with the quality of their public education.

Rosy teacher evaluations contradict student progress
St. Petersburg Tribune, FL, December 8, 2013
A sweeping majority of Florida’s teachers seem to be performing to the highest standards in the classroom, the newest round of evaluations say. However, some education experts say those findings contradict new reports on student achievement, and hint at bigger problems with the state’s accountability system.

GEORGIA

Savannah-Chatham’s poorest schools use federal money to catch up
Savannah Morning Journal, GA, December 7, 2013
Savannah-Chatham’s public education system includes 32 schools in which 48 percent all the way up to 100 percent of the students live at or below the poverty level.

INDIANA

Charter School of the Dunes working to meet objectives
NW Times, IN, December 9, 2013
Officials at Calumet College of St. Joseph are keeping a close eye on the Charter School of the Dunes.

Tensions Rise as Indiana Schools Chief and Governor Clash Over New Agency
New York Times, NY, December 9, 2013
For Glenda Ritz, who took office as Indiana’s top education official this year, the awkward reality of being the lone statewide elected Democrat here did not take long to blossom into all-out combat.

ILLINOIS

Chicago officials try to tackle K-8 grade truancy crisis
Chicago Tribune, IL, December 8, 2013
Top Chicago school authorities are working on new strategies to address the city’s crushing pattern of elementary grade absenteeism and truancy.

Chicago schools transition­ _ smooth or rocky?
Associated Press, December 8, 2013
Devion Allen peers wistfully through a door window at the school he used to attend. Those who live outside his gritty, violence-plagued neighborhood might dismiss this towering brick building as just another failing urban school.

How will UNO fare after Rangel?
Editorial, Chicago Tribune, IL, December 9, 2013
Most important: Many of those UNO schools excelled academically, providing a quality education to thousands of students. UNO became a model for how to expand a charter network and maintain high standards.

School works only if kids show up
Opinion, Chicago Sun Times, IL, December 9, 2013
Nothing a school does matters much if the kids don’t show up. As red-hot debates continue over how best to improve schools — More testing or less testing?

KENTUCKY

Survey: Kentuckians ‘Undecided’ On Charter Schools, but Favor Charter-Like Features
WFPL, KY, December 8, 2013
More than half of Kentuckians contacted for a new survey released this week say they’re undecided on whether the state’s public education system would improve with charter schools.

LOUISIANA

Jindal teacher reviews frozen
The Advocate, LA, December 9, 2013
Gov. Bobby Jindal’s hard-fought bid to link teacher job reviews to the growth of student achievement — a key plank in his push to improve Louisiana’s public schools — has been sidelined until after he leaves office.

MISSOURI

Missouri proposal to change early childhood teacher certification faces criticism
St. Louis Post-Dispatch, MO, December 9, 2013
Early childhood education proponents in Missouri say a state proposal to change teaching certification standards may hurt kindergartners and repel new teachers from pursuing careers with younger students.

NEW JERSEY

Funding one school district at the expense of another
Letter, Hudson Reporter, NJ, December 8, 2013
At the November 12th Hoboken Public School Board meeting, parents of children enrolled in the HoLa Charter School spoke in favor of expanding their school district by two new grade levels. Why were parents from HoLa speaking at the Hoboken Public School district meeting?

NEW MEXICO

Double dipping by teachers is on the rise
Albuquerque Journal, NM, December 9, 2013
When New Mexico lawmakers banned the practice of retiree double dipping in 2010, the ban applied to almost all types of public employees – but not teachers.

NEW YORK

A third way on education reform
Opinion, New York Daily News, NY, December 9, 2013
Mayor-elect de Blasio vowed to bring New York’s “two cities” together. When it comes to education, he’s got his work cut out. The city — like the nation — is locked in a bitter fight over education that leaves little room for cooperation.

‘Day of Action’ planned by NY teachers, union
Wall Street Journal, December 9, 2013
Teachers across New York will wear blue and rally for more funding and less testing as part of a national “Day of Action” organized across numerous states.

De Blasio Taking Slow and Steady Approach to Schools Chancellor Pick
Observer Sunday, NY, December 8, 2013
Bill de Blasio will be unveiling “important” new appointments in the near future, but don’t expect his schools chancellor pick to be among them.

It’s about the kids, Bill
Opinion, New York Daily News, NY, December 8, 2013
The mayor-elect is on the cusp of tapping a new chancellor to lead New York City’s largest-in-the-nation, 1.1 million student public education system. One bellwether of the new educator-in-chief’s determination to stand with the kids will be his or her approach to charter schools.

NORTH CAROLINA

State model outlines post-tenure teacher contracts
Burlington Times News, NC, December 7, 2013
A model for new teacher contracts approved this week by the N.C. Board of Education could leave local school districts across the state on the hook for $90 million in teacher raises.

OHIO

58% of Columbus third-graders fail state exam, risk being held back
Columbus Dispatch, OH, December 8, 2013
Sometime before May, when they take the reading test again, more than 2,350 Columbus third-graders have to get better.

PENNSYLVANIA

Charter schools are boon to school districts
Letter, The Sentinel, PA, December 7, 2013
Your recent editorial (“Charter school bill would burden taxpayers,” The Sentinel, Nov. 30) criticizing proposed charter and cyber-charter school reform perpetuates several myths that limit educational innovation and opportunity.

New charter school bill in State Senate won’t be any easy sell
Delaware County Daily Times, PA, December 8, 2013
There is little argument among state legislators and educators that Pennsylvania’s charter school law needs substantial changes.

Pa. schools and $$ behind the curtain
Column, Philadelphia Daily News, PA, December 9, 2013
ARE MOST Pennsylvania school districts fooling Pennsylvania taxpayers? Are they hoarding money while annually seeking more while poorer districts, including Philly’s, operate in crisis?

Public-school advocates fear pending revision of Pa. charter rules
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, December 8, 2013
Its sponsors say it is an urgently needed and long-overdue package of reforms for a burgeoning system, but critics contend that Pennsylvania’s hotly debated charter-school bill would speed the decline of some conventional public schools.

SOUTH CAROLINA

Students, families benefit from more school choices
Editorial, Hilton Head Island Packet, SC, December 8, 2013
The Beaufort County School District should endorse a plan for more programmatic choices.

TENNESSEE

New charter school funding plan floated
The Tennessean, TN, December 8, 2013
Charter school pioneers willing to go where Metro wants them to go could soon be offered a boost: public money to help them turn old malls and stores into new schoolhouses.

VIRGINIA

Goal
Editorial, Richmond Post-Dispatch, VA, December 9, 2013
A unanimous Richmond School Board scored a goal on behalf of a worthy goal when it voted to require students to maintain a 2.0 grade-point average if they want to play on sports teams.

WASHINGTON

Lessons for locals on power of parents in schools
Seattle Times, WA, December 7, 2013
A community group in northwest Chicago has turned hundreds of hesitant parents into capable classroom helpers, role models and leaders by tapping into strengths many don’t realize they have.

WISCONSIN

Unified charter schools march to own drummer, checkbook
Kenosha News, WI, December 7, 2013
When principals leave traditional neighborhood schools to lead charter schools in Kenosha, they add another title to the list of responsibilities: budget director.

ONLINE LEARNING

Making virtual schools sustainable, accountable
Opinion, Ocala Star Banner, FL, December 8, 2013
There have been recent media stories questioning the quality of virtual education. Most recently, under the headline “Cyber schools flunk, but the money keeps flowing,” Politico reported on the poor performance of students taking online courses from various providers in a variety of states.

Online charters: Court rightly provides precious oversight time
Winston Salem-Journal, NC, December 8, 2013
The N.C. Court of Appeals has provided the General Assembly with precious time to fix an oversight in the state’s charter schools law. Legislators must not let this opportunity slip away.

Daily Headlines for December 6, 2013

Click here for Newswire, the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else – spiced with a dash of irreverence – from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

NATIONAL COVERAGE

Is the U.S. making the grade in education?
Opinion, Washington Post, DC, December 6, 2013
The latest international student evaluations, the PISA test results, are out, and one thing is clear: The United States has not done well.

US undeserving of dunce cap
Column, Wilkes Barre Times-Leader, PA, December 6, 2013
Even if you’re not an education news geek, you almost certainly heard at least a hint of the collective gnashing of teeth upon the release of the latest international school test results.

STATE COVERAGE

CALIFORNIA

Aspire teachers at center of fierce national debate
San Francisco Chronicle, CA, December 5, 2013
When Eva Kellogg’s bosses evaluated her performance as a teacher, they observed her classes. They reviewed her lesson plans. They polled her students, their parents and other teachers. And then they took a look at her students’ standardized test scores.

Livermore Charter Schools Examine Ideas for Expansion
The Independent, CA, December 6, 2013
The Tri-Valley Learning Corporation (TVLC), which operates charter a K-8 and a high school in Livermore, has been discussing the merits of expanding the number of schools it administers, with an eye toward helping its Livermore programs gain more money.

FLORIDA

Both sides in teacher evaluation debate need dose of reality
Column, Tampa Bay Times, FL, December 5, 2013
They live in parallel universes, each one a creation of misguided hope. On one side are the politicians who seem convinced that every classroom is identical, and the only reason students fail is because their teachers are inept. On the other side are educators who see a world that’s out to get them, and reflexively protect their own whether they are deserving or not.

Failing schools with “highly effective” teachers
WEAR-TV, FL, December 6, 2013
Nearly 98 percent of Florida’s teachers are “effective” or “highly effective”, according to ratings recently released by the state. But some are asking how that’s possible when Florida has a record high number of F-rated schools statewide, including some in our area.

MacDill charter school gets preliminary ‘no’ from Hillsborough officials
Tampa Bay Times, FL, December 6, 2013
Hillsborough school officials are poised to deny the application for a new charter school at MacDill Air Force Base, citing concerns about the way it would be governed.

Reconsider notion of city-run charter school
Editorial, Palm Beach Post, FL, December 5, 2013
West Palm Beach is moving ahead with plans to open the area’s first city-run charter school, a proposal that sounds great in theory. After all, the school is intended to improve education for children in some of the city’s poorest neighborhoods, where Mayor Jeri Muoio has called students’ performance on reading tests “totally unacceptable.”

IDAHO

Idaho governor defends openness, goals of Common Core
Idaho Statesman, ID, December 6, 2013
In an online chat, Otterr and panelists say education reform will raise the bar for Idaho schools.

INDIANA

Parent, teacher fear for creativity
The Journal Gazette, IN, December 6, 2013
A local educator and parent have mixed opinions about whether Indiana should move forward with the adoption of the Common Core education standards.

Pence seeks pre-K vouchers, road money in 2nd year
Herald Bulletin, IN, December 5, 2013
Indiana’s school voucher program, already the broadest in the nation, would be expanded to preschool-aged children under a plan Gov. Mike Pence announced Thursday as part of his 2014 agenda.

ILLINOIS

CPS Delays Posting of Charter School Proposals
DNAinfo , IL, December 5, 2013
Those hoping to get a more detailed look at the proposals for new charter schools in the city will have to wait a bit longer.

LOUISIANA

Baton Rouge superintendent plans foreign language magnet at Polk, new middle school at Brookstown
Times-Picayune, LA, December 5, 2013
More shifting of school boundaries is likely on the way in Baton Rouge, as School Board members heard on Thursday night about plans to change the programs at Polk Elementary and Brookstown Elementary.

MICHIGAN

Critics rip school grading bill
Detroit News, MI, December 6, 2013
Legislation creating a letter grading system for Michigan public schools is coming under scrutiny because it contains a provision that may speed the transfer of failing schools into the troubled Education Achievement Authority.

MISSOURI

Support school’s faith-based education
Letter, St. Louis Post-Dispatch, MO, December 6, 2013
The letter “Can’t compare De La Salle to a public school” (Nov. 24) was disappointing but correct in one way. De La Salle Middle School in north St. Louis, with total enrollment capped at 65 students, can’t provide all the services of a vast public school system.

NEW JERSEY

East Brunswick charter school finally expands into long-denied building
Cranbury Road, NJ, December 5, 2013
The 272 kindergarten-to-fifth-grade students of Hatikvah International Academy Charter School appear to be thrilled to have more space and a larger gym in their new Lexington Avenue building, which they moved into on Monday.

NEW YORK

Icahn Charter Schools walks away from controversial colocation plan in Bronx
New York Daily News, NY, December 5, 2013
Educator won approval to open charter high school in Gunther Ave. middle school that already housed Pelham Gardens Middle School and Junior High School 144.

NORTH CAROLINA

Educators warn teacher turnover numbers to rise unless pay issue is addressed
Fayetteville Observer, NC, December 5, 2013
The state will continue to see an increase in the number of teachers leaving their jobs if the issue of teacher pay is not addressed, local educators say.

PENNSYLVANIA

A fortified future
Opinion, South Philly Review, PA, December 5, 2013
With the closures of many schools in the School District of Philadelphia, 186th District state Rep. Jordan Harris has proposed legislation that would add three new members to the School Reform Commission. These new members would include a parent representative from both charter and public schools and the president of the city-wide student government association.

Alternative education
Letter, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, December 6, 2013
The Nov. 20 article addressing Clayton Academy and its attempt to extend the contract it has with the Pittsburgh Public Schools (“Alternative School Seeks Contract Extension With City”) quotes Kenneth Huston, an employee of the company that runs Clayton, as saying, “If they weren’t at Clayton Academy, where would those kids be?”

TEXAS

High dropout rate is everybody’s problem
Editorial, Beaumont Enterprise, TX, December 6, 2013
Anyone looking for a simple solution to the problem of high school dropouts won’t find it. The causes are many, ranging from pregnancy to homelessness. But one thing about this issue is clear: Every person, business, charity or governmental agency that can keep one kid in school is doing a great deed – and needs all the support others can muster.

Texas charter schools flexing their muscles
Column, Fort Worth Star Telegram, TX, December 5, 2013
Texas charter schools are getting more respect these days — look no further than the support they got from lawmakers who this year approved the most significant rewrite of charter legislation since they authorized the concept in 1995.

UTAH

U.S. education secretary praises school improvement efforts at Northwest Middle
Deseret News, UT, December 6, 2013
For the past three years, Northwest Middle School has been working to increase student achievement with the help of a $2.3 million grant from the U.S. Department of Education.

ONLINE LEARNING

Online-only school is an effort worth pursuing
Editorial, York Daily Journal, NC, December 5, 2013
Sometimes we can’t help but feel the system is rigged against change. Change isn’t always a bad thing.

Schools line up for virtual classrooms
Marietta Times, OH, December 6, 2013
Area schools are attempting to provide more educational options and recapture some of the students – and money – they’ve lost to online community schools in recent years by offering their own virtual classrooms.

Postcards From The Past – No. 3

Postcards from the Past 
A new, occasional blog post in commemoration of CER’s 20 years in business and the historical events that have taken place during our history and the history of the education reform movement.

In 1996, CER created the first-ever national charter school directory,  an invaluable resource that continues to provide up-to-date information on charter school enrollment data and contact information, as well as overviews of charter missions and goals. Back then, a print version of all that information could be accessed for a modest fee (plus shipping and handling).

Now, there’s an app for that.

In New York City, government officials and software developers are recognizing the needs of families to access reliable school data. With increased educational alternatives available to students, families are now compelled to examine information on different schools to find the option that’s right for them.

The ease at which NYC families can access this technology demonstrates the positive effects and popularity of having access to school data. Transparency of information is a hallmark of Parent Power, which will hopefully continue to expand beyond this Big Apple app and continue to expand as more innovative ways of reaching parents and supplying information are created.

 

 

Daily Headlines for December 5, 2013

Click here for Newswire, the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else – spiced with a dash of irreverence – from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

NATIONAL COVERAGE

Education Dept. spells out five charter school priorities
Washington Post Blog, DC, December 4, 2013
The U.S. Education Department under Secretary Arne Duncan has for years been supportive of public charter schools, even requiring states that wanted Race to the Top money or federal waivers from No Child Left Behind to expand their numbers. Now the department is trying to figure out what requirements to attach to future federal grants for charter schools, and is seeking public comment on its proposed priorities as spelled out in the Federal Register (text of notice below).

Teachers Union Blame Game
Opinion, Wall Street Journal, December 5, 2013
The teacher unions’ response to the mediocre performance of American students on international tests has been instructive. American kids are in the middle of the pack in science and reading and lag badly in math, according to the latest Program for International Students Assessment (PISA), which surveys 15-year-old students in developed nations.

Teachers union chief offers four steps to boost US results on PISA test
Christian Science Monitor, December 4, 2013
At a Monitor-hosted breakfast, Randi Weingarten, president of the 1.5-million-member American Federation of Teachers, said the US could look to other countries for ways to improve the lackluster performance on the PISA test.

STATE COVERAGE

CALIFORNIA
LASD counters charter school’s enrollment forecast
Los Altos Town Crier, CA, December 4, 2013
The Los Altos School District countered Bullis Charter School’s projected enrollment for the 2014-2015 school year last week, calculating 73 fewer students than the charter school’s estimation.

San Jose charter school helps salvage lives
Contra Costa Times, CA, December 4, 2013
After they veer off course, many of California’s hundreds of thousands of dropouts end up unemployed, on the streets, in jail and worse. For those young people who are lucky and determined enough, the San Jose Conservation Corps Charter School has helped them get back on track.

COLORADO

Language-oriented charter school building permanent digs in west Fort Collins
Coloradoan, CO, December 4, 2013
After months of hunting for a permanent home while sharing living quarters with a Fort Collins church, a state-approved charter school intends to plant roots in west Fort Collins.

CONNECTICUT

Stamford looks at magnet schools to solve crowding
Connecticut Post, CT, December 5, 2013
After lots of meetings and discussions, Stamford Schools Superintendent Winifred Hamilton recommended the Board of Education build a new magnet school and increase enrollment in elementary and middle school magnet programs already up and running to solve overcrowding problems

GEORGIA

Schools should get evaluation choices
Eatonton Messenger, GA, December 5, 2013
The Putnam County schools chose to become a “charter” system several years ago. The ability to make that choice was a much ballyhooed move by the state legislature to help schools improve.

FLORIDA

Florida public school teacher evaluation system too flawed
Editorial, Bradenton Herald, FL, December 5, 201
Imagine an annual performance evaluation whereby the employer ranks workers based on responsibilities they don’t even have. Like a brick mason held accountable for the wooden frame of a house.

Start over on teacher accountability
Tampa Bay Times, FL, December 5, 2013
Floridians already can’t trust the state’s public school grading system after years of arbitrary changes by the Legislature that produced meaningless results.

IDAHO

Is Idaho bound for a Common Core war?
Idaho Statesman, ID, December 4, 2013
A Statesman survey shows division in legislative committees that could decide the new education curriculum’s fate.

ILLINOIS

A cannon shot from Detroit
Editorial, Chicago Tribune, IL, December 5, 2013
The situation is even more acute at Chicago Public Schools. The school system faces about a $1 billion deficit next year, largely driven by rising pension payments. CPS exhausted its reserves to help close a massive budget gap this year.

KENTUCKY

State’s takeover of Breathitt schools could end ahead of schedule
Lexington Herald-Leader, KY, December 4, 2013
An attorney for five Breathitt County school board members said they had reached a settlement that could signal an earlier end to the state’s control over the district.

LOUISIANA

Tangipahoa board rejects two charter applications
The Advocate, LA, December 4, 213
The Tangipahoa Parish School Board on Wednesday denied two charter school applications and tabled discussion on another.

MAINE

Bangor councilors likely to extend charter school moratorium as talks with state delayed
Bangor Daily News, ME, December 4, 2013
The Bangor City Council likely will extend its temporary ban on charter schools into next summer in order to hash out a disagreement with the state about how new competition for students would affect the public school system and Bangor taxpayers.

High schools can make the grade without credential
Portland Press Herald, ME, December 5, 2013
The public secondary schools in Portland and elsewhere that are forgoing accreditation have other ways to ensure accountability.

State gives high marks to Portland charter school
The Forecaster, ME, December 4, 2013
A charter school that opened this fall in the city is as “good as it gets,” according to a 90-day review from the state’s Charter School Commission.

MICHIGAN

Good steps toward school accountability
Editorial, Detroit News, MI, December 5, 2013
For the past two years, education reform has remained a topic of hot debate in the Michigan Legislature. And no wonder. Schools affect the majority of families, and education accounts for roughly 30 percent of the state budget. So the issues of funding and accountability are always top-of-mind.

Super: Bill would lead to aging 3rd grade
Daily Press Argus, MI, December 5, 2013
A bill GOP legislators claim would reduce Michigan’s high school dropout rate could conceivably result in third-graders being old enough to drive to school, a Livingston County school official said.

MINNESOTA

St. Paul, Mpls. schools are rated low on closing achievement gap
Star Tribune, MN, December 5, 2013
The Minneapolis and St. Paul school districts rank poorly for their achievement gaps, but better than average on improving student test proficiency, judged against a select group of big-city peers nationally, according to a foundation that describes itself as libertarian.

MISSISSIPPI

Miss. can delay high-stakes teacher evaluations
Hattiesburg American, MS, December 4, 2013
The federal government has granted Mississippi permission for a one-year delay in the use of evaluations to hire and fire teachers.

NEW JERSEY

N.J. high school graduation rate grows to 87.5 percent
Star-Ledger, NJ, December 5, 2013
New Jersey’s high school graduation rate rose slightly again last year to 87.5 percent statewide, according to data from the department of education.

NEW YORK

465 students transferred to Buffalo public schools from charters in past 4 months
Buffalo News, NY, December 5, 2013
Over the last four months, 465 students have transferred out of city charter schools and into Buffalo public schools. The overwhelming majority cited “parental choice” as the reason for the transfer, according to the report provided to the School Board on Wednesday.

City’s grad rate hits record high
New York Post, NY, December 5, 2013
Despite stagnating in recent years, the graduation rate at city public high schools edged up to an all-time high this past school year — hitting 66 percent, according to city measures.

NORTH CAROLINA

New Hanover school board stands with teachers against state tenure changes
Port City Daily, NC, December 4, 2013
Standing with local educators, the New Hanover County Board of Education has taken a formal stance against state lawmakers’ decision to do away with teacher tenure.

Teacher turnover in North Carolina reaches five-year high
News & Observer, NC, December 4, 2013
Teacher turnover in North Carolina reached a five-year high last year with more teachers leaving their classrooms to take new jobs in education or move.

OHIO

Senate OKs minor change to teacher evaluations
Toledo Blade, OH, December 5, 2013
Before heading for the door for the holidays, the Ohio Senate on Wednesday unanimously approved a bill that would loosen some of the restrictions placed on new teacher evaluations.

TENNESSEE

As more parents flex their school-choice options, some MNPS schools are operating far below capacity
Nashville Scene, TN
December 5, 2013
At this fall’s First Choice Festival, principals found themselves competing for every one of them. But for every student one school received, another school’s enrollment went down by one. And at several Metro schools, the students lost far outnumber the ones attracted.

Put school money where it will work
Column, The Tennessean, TN, December 5, 2013
Where goes Will Pinkston, so shortly follows the thermonuclear incident, or so it seems. But let me also say something positive about this man of sharp elbows, who for all intents and purposes is the head of our local school board: He understands we have a spending problem at Metro Nashville Public Schools. And he’s trying to do something about it.

Vanderbilt study examining Nashville charter, magnet school attrition
The Tennessean, TN, December 5, 2013
Graduate students at Vanderbilt University are wading into one of Metro schools’ mostly politically charged questions: Do Nashville’s charter schools really see more students leave before end-of-year testing than other public schools?

WASHINGTON

A rare moment of bipartisanship on Idaho school reform
Spokesman Review, WA, December 4, 2013
In a rare moment of bipartisanship on school reform in Idaho, Democratic state lawmakers unveiled four far-reaching bills Wednesday, and GOP state schools Superintendent Tom Luna endorsed them.

ONLINE LEARNING

iPads emerge as a cool tool for school
Florida Today, FL, December 5, 2013
On a recent morning at Florida Air Academy, a private day and boarding school near downtown Melbourne, students weren’t using paper and pencils in their algebra I class.

Julie Young: Virtual school is changing education
Column, Tallahassee Democrat, FL, December 5, 2013
There have been recent articles questioning the quality of virtual education. Most recently, under the headline “Cyber schools flunk, but the money keeps flowing,” Politico reported on the poor performance of students taking online courses from various providers in a variety of states.

Tech gurus help boost speedy internet in schools
Associated Press, December 5, 2013
Needed to keep a school building running these days: Water, electricity – and broadband.

NYC Data? There’s An App for That

As districts across the country have become more diverse and students are able to attend schools not determined by their zip code, the need for accessible education data has grown exponentially.

Education Week reported this week on the School Choice Design Challenge, which resulted in the creation of six mobile applications or ‘apps,’ with which students can compare data on the city’s 732 high school programs.

The apps – created at the relatively low cost of $72,000 – allow for side-by-side comparisons of schools, and have reportedly become useful for low-income and immigrant families in search of educational alternatives.

The ease at which NYC families can access this technology demonstrates the positive effects and popularity of having access to school data. Transparency of information is a hallmark of Parent Power, which will hopefully continue to expand beyond this Big Apple app.

California Parents Hungry for More Power

In California, more communities are finding new and innovative ways to bolster Parent Power. Numerous civil rights groups and community activists are organizing parents to wield more influence in schools and increase access to administrators, while also educating them on issues such as budgeting and disciplinary practices.

Recent initiatives from California parents include questioning the performance of a school principal in Cudahy, CA, combating the unionization of classroom aides, and demanding more input in the state budgeting process.

This past fall, former California legislator Gloria Romero recalled writing the first-ever parent trigger law in the United States, enabling parents to decide to take action when their neighborhood school is failing their children.

It’s clear that the legacy of parent empowerment is spreading three years after Romero drafted that monumental piece of legislation.

And it’s not just in Calfornia. Parental input and influence in education is gaining traction across the country, as evidenced by the 72 percent of Americans who have a favorable opinion of the term ‘parent choice,’ according to CER’s recent national survey.

The decision of activists and self-described civil rights groups to take up the cause of parent empowerment is a testament to the truth that education is the civil rights issue of our time, and students and parents have an inherent right to choose the quality education that’s right for them.

Daily Headlines for December 4, 2013

Click here for Newswire, the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else – spiced with a dash of irreverence – from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

NATIONAL COVERAGE

Let’s Call Off the Education Arms Race
Opinion, Wall Street Journal, December 3, 2013
On Tuesday, the highly anticipated results of the Program for International Student Assessment were released—and like clockwork, out came a barrage of media stories hyping the results.

PISA test shows ‘stagnation.’ Is US education reform failing?
Christian Science Monitor, MA, December 3, 2013
In the 2012 PISA test comparing educational performance worldwide, US teenagers were stuck at average in reading and science, and below average in mathematics. Other countries improved.

Sense and Sustainability in Education Reform
Opinion, Huffington Post, December 3, 2013
It’s a question that’s daunted educators for decades: Why haven’t well-intentioned efforts to improve teaching and learning in our schools had the kind of impact we want and need?

STATE COVERAGE

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

D.C. Council votes unanimously to give schools more money for at-risk kids
Washington Post, DC, December 3, 2013
The D.C. Council gave its tentative but unanimous approval Tuesday to a bill that would funnel extra dollars to public schools serving low-income students and others at risk of academic failure.

GEORGIA

Atlanta school board elections bring heavy turnover
Atlanta Journal-Constitution, GA, December 4, 2013
Two-thirds of Atlanta’s school board will be filled with new representatives following a runoff election Tuesday that ousted the board’s chairman.

FLORIDA

Charter school’s $400,000 ‘grant’ to Doral College draws questions from auditors
Miami Herald, FL, December 3, 2013
Fledgling Doral College got a $400,000 windfall two years ago that helped the small start-up open its doors. The “grant” came from Doral Academy Charter High, a publicly funded school run by the same company.

Schools making the grade in state’s new evaluations
Tampa Tribune, FL, December 4, 2013
The majority of local teachers, as well as those across the state, once again received good evaluations, according to preliminary data released by the Florida Department of Education on Tuesday.

ILLINOIS

Teachers, unions unhappy with pension deal, vow legal challenge
Chicago Daily Herald, IL, December 3, 2013
In the aftermath of the Illinois House and Senate passing pension reform legislation Tuesday, leaders of several suburban teachers unions said they were unhappy with the deal and vowed to continue the fight in the courts.

LOUISIANA

KIPP leadership to vote on returning to Orleans school board
The Lens, LA, December 3, 2013
The board of directors of KIPP New Orleans Schools plans to vote on whether to return several of it charter schools to Orleans Parish School Board oversight at a board meeting Dec. 19.

MASSACHUSETTS

Boston Promise Corps program unveiled at Dudley Street Neighborhood Charter School
Boston Globe, MA, December 3, 2013
Governor Deval Patrick’s message was clear as he joined other elected officials and education advocates today to unveil the Boston Promise Corps program: a zip code should not determine a child’s future.

Flawed evaluation system betrays teachers, taxpayers
Editorial, Gloucester Daily Times, MA
December 4, 2013
When Gloucester teachers hand out grades to their students, those students, their parents — and, yes, school administrators — have a right to assume the grades are fair and accurate, right?

MICHIGAN

Almost 220,000 Michigan Public School Students Rely On School Choice
Michigan Capital Confidential, MI, December 4, 2013
Charter public schools blamed for problems with traditional public schools, but parents choose charters and other alternatives for their kids

EMU education dean leaving EAA board
Detroit News, MI, December 3, 2013
The dean of Eastern Michigan University’s College of Education has left the board that oversees the state’s recovery school district, as faculty members push for the university to end its partnership with the Education Achievement Authority.

NEW JERSEY

Camden Renaissance school plans criticized
Courier Post, NJ, December 4, 2013
The request for proposals comes before the district has completed work on its first application, filed jointly by KIPP, a charter school chain, and charitable foundations for Cooper University Hospital and the Norcross family.

NEW MEXICO

APS board to discuss member’s test boycott idea
Albuquerque Journal, NM, December 4, 2013
The Albuquerque school board tonight will discuss the potential ramifications of a testing boycott being advocated by one of its members.

NEW YORK

Levin pushes for moratorium on charter schools
Brooklyn Eagle, NY, December 3, 2013
Charging that the city is facing skyrocketing costs for charter schools, Councilman Stephen Levin has introduced a resolution in the council calling on the Department of Education to place a moratorium on new charter schools.

Showdown on Tuition for the Disabled
Wall Street Journal, December 3, 2013
More parents in New York state are enrolling their children with special needs in private schools and seeking taxpayer-funded tuition payments under a federal law. New York City, for example, will spend an estimated $223 million in 2013-14 on private-school tuition, up from about $63 million in the 2007-08 school year, according to the city’s Independent Budget Office.

Speculating on de Blasio’s Choice for Schools Chief
New York Times, NY, December 4, 2013
It might normally be of little interest that Joshua P. Starr, a Maryland schools superintendent, spent the Thanksgiving holiday in Brooklyn, dining on crispy beef tongue fries and visiting a Jean Paul Gaultier exhibit.

OHIO

Senate bill would allow students to help grade teachers
Toledo Blade, OH, December 4, 2013
In a development some may relish, students may get chances to help grade their teachers under a fast-tracked bill headed for an Ohio Senate vote as soon as today.

OKLAHOMA

Fewer dropouts
Editorial, Tulsa World, OK, December 4, 2013
Here’s a good news story about Tulsa Public Schools at a time when we could use one.
TPS saw a nearly 18 percent decrease in middle school, junior high and high school dropouts last year, the district reports.

PENNSYLVANIA

GOP pushes performance-based teacher furloughs in Pennsylvania
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, December 4, 2013
Currently, state law allows teachers to be laid off only for reasons related to declines in student enrollment or changes in the organization of a school or district.

Selling ads on school buildings wins early backing
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, December 4, 2013
City Council moved Tuesday on a long-percolating idea to raise money for the School District of Philadelphia – by selling advertising space on district buildings.

SOUTH CAROLINA

Haley focuses attention on education reform
Spartanburg Herald Journal, SC, December 3, 2013
Gov. Nikki Haley laid the groundwork Tuesday for a new education reform package she plans to unveil in January.

TENNESSEE

Questions outnumber answers on IA’s future
Kingsport Times News, TN, December 3, 2013
Parents and prospective parents of Innovation Academy of Northeast Tennessee students had more questions than Sullivan County Director of Schools Jubal Yennnie had answers Tuesday night.

Thousands Apply For Metro’s Optional Schools
WTVF-TV, TN, December 3, 2013
Thousands of hopeful parents have applied for Metropolitan Nashville Public Schools’ Optional Schools.

WASHINGTON

Charter schools following an upward trajectory
Editorial, News Tribune, WA, December 4, 2013
Washington is getting its first glimpse of what public charter schools will look like in this state. Eight of them are to be launched next year under Initiative 1240, approved by the voters last year. Three nonprofit organizations propose to open schools in Tacoma; another nonprofit seeks to create one near Joint Base Lewis-McChord.

ONLINE LEARNING

Two groups again seek OK for online Maine charter schools
Portland Press Herald, ME, December 4, 2013
They try a third time for state approval while two other groups file for brick-and-mortar charter schools.

NC virtual charter group rebuffed by NC Court of Appeals
Charlotte Observer, NC, December 3, 2013
RALEIGH A charter school that had planned to open in the fall of 2012 and offer only online classes failed to convince the N.C. Court of Appeals that it should have been allowed to move forward with its plan without approval by the State Board of Education.

Virtual High School courses offer extras for students, insight into demand
Valley Breeze, RI, December 3, 2013
Students and teachers are seeing the benefits of boosting the existing curriculum with online courses, which have, in turn, even prompted changes within the school walls.

U.S. Students Slide on International Measure

Joy Pullmann, The Heartland Institute 

The latest international test scores, released Tuesday, show U.S. students sliding further behind their global counterparts in math, reading, and science.

On the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), a test administered every three years, U.S. students came in 20th in reading in 2012. In 2009, they were tenth. On math, U.S. students ranked 30th this year. In 2009, they ranked 24th. And in science, U.S. students were 23rd of the more than 65 countries tested, four below their 2009 ranking.

The results generated a raft of concerned statements.

“With all the available resources and innovation that occurs within the United States, it’s inexcusable that we have not yet embraced the necessary reforms to significantly boost student outcomes,” said Kara Kerwin, president of the Center for Education Reform (CER).

“Our kids trail…most of the industrialized world and lag far behind countries like Germany, Korea, Canada, and Australia, to say nothing of the broad grouping of East Asian countries at the top,” said Paul Peterson, who directs the Program on Education Policy and Governance at Harvard University. “This embarrassing performance, unchanged even as politicians and citizens profess a keen interest in improving our schools, bodes poorly for the future economic security of the United States.”

Overall, U.S. students were at about the international average in reading and science and below-average in math. Connecticut, Florida, and Massachusetts chose to separate their results. Massachusetts and Connecticut ranked above average when compared internationally, while Florida was at the U.S. average.

High Spending, Mediocre Results
The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development administers PISA to fifteen-year-olds across the world. OECD also found that the United States spends more than every country on K-12 education except for four. This means nearly all the countries whose students perform better than U.S. students spend less to get better results.

OECD’s report notes that the Slovak Republic performs at the same level as the United States, but spends an average of $62,000 less per student from age 6 to 15. The U.S. spends nearly $13,000 per K-12 student per year.

“Korea, the highest-performing OECD country in mathematics, spends well below the average per-student expenditure,” the report notes.

“This drop represents not only a threat to our economic competitiveness but also demonstrates that the system as it has been functioning for decades is no longer viable,” Kerwin said.

Choice and Information
Kerwin recommended that policy makers quickly give families more information and choices in education, reforms proven to improve student outcomes.

The results show “the dire need to entertain more radical changes in our stagnant schools: more choice, more performance pay, and more local decision-making,” said Eric Hanushek, a Hoover Institution senior fellow. “Each of these will help America’s kids, however, only if there is also a good system of standardized testing that identifies failing schools and holds them accountable.  Then, when the next round of international test scores is released in 2016, we may finally have some genuine good news.”