Sign up for our newsletter

National Report Card for Parents Released

Top Ten States on Parent Power Index© provide roadmap for lawmakers 

CER Press Release
Washington, D.C.
January 22, 2013

The nation’s “Top Ten” states that provide more expansive opportunities for parents also tend to yield higher growth rates in student achievement, according to the most recent national rankings on the Parent Power Index© (PPI) released today by The Center for Education Reform (CER). Indiana ranks No. 1, followed by Florida, Ohio, Arizona, D.C., Louisiana, Minnesota, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Utah, in enacting policies that allow for more parental empowerment, expansive educational choices, sound teacher quality measures, wider access to digital learning and more transparent data. These states’ policies correlate highly with increased student growth, particularly among lower socio-economic students, over time.

The PPI is an interactive, web-based tool that ranks the United States based on how much power a parent has over their children’s education. While there is a growing body of data and information available to parents, policymakers, educators and the general public, the PPI is the first and only comprehensive evaluation of state education policy that is geared towards parents, continuously updated in real-time, and now, provides an arsenal of state and local resources.

“All across America, parents are demanding more power over their children’s education, but the task of sorting through all the information out there is daunting,” said Jeanne Allen, president of CER. “There are a variety of resources available to evaluate how students are achieving, but there is widespread disagreement about what constitutes sound education reform policy.” Allen continued: “As the mother of college students, I liken the PPI to a cumulative GPA, which is a composite of grades from varying professors. In this case, these professors are among the nation’s leading authorities and critical evaluators of education policy.”

The latest rankings on the Parent Power Index© are a resulte of the release of CER’s 14th annual Charter School Laws Across the States Ranking and Scorecard 2013. Washington became the 43rd state to allow charter schools and only four other states made improvements to their charter laws last year.

In addition to charter schools, the Index evaluates states on school choice using data and analysis provided by the The Friedman Foundation for Educational Choice, The National Council on Teacher Quality’s detailed analysis in its annual State Teacher Policy Yearbook, Digital Learning Now’s evaluation of state policies based on 72 metrics, transparency of data, school board elections and Parent Revolution’s analysis of parent trigger laws. It also looks at local media reliability on education issues and if state executives are reform-minded. Further evaluation across all of these Elements of Power is ongoing and continuously updated at https://2024.edreform.com/in-the-states/parent-power-index/.

The Parent Power Index© also reveals that a majority of states are barely making the grade when it comes to policies that allow parents to exercise choices, engage with local school boards and have a voice in the education systems that surround their children.

“The Index’s ‘Top Ten’ prove that when parents have access to options and good information all children can succeed,” Allen said. “Lawmakers need to look to these exemplars and the policies that have afforded parents greater power elsewhere and act fast to bring real education reform to their respective states. Parents and voters have declared that mediocrity is no longer acceptable, and our elected officials have a mandate to fix our educational and economic problems for good.”

Daily Headlines for January 21, 2013

NEWSWIRE IS BACK! Click here for the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else, spiced with a dash of irreverence, from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

NATIONAL COVERAGE

Time To Put Education Spotlight On Parents
San Angelo Times, TX, January 21, 2013

Turnabout is fair play, and in no arena as much as that of student academic achievement.

FROM THE STATES

CALIFORNIA

Teachers OK LAUSD Evaluation Standards
Daily Breeze, CA, January 19, 2013

After months of negotiations, the Los Angeles Unified School District and its teachers union have reached a compromise that will now use a controversial multifactor system to evaluate teacher performance.

COLORADO

Truancy Court As A Last Resort
Denver Post, CO, January 20, 2013

Commerce City should consider a system of community and school interventions before sending truant children to court.

GEORGIA

New Evaluations Might Be An Improvement, Teacher Says
Dalton Daily Citizen, GA, January 21, 2013

Sometimes, 20 minutes is all an employee has to impress a boss. That can be especially true for public school teachers.

Teacher Evaluations: Is There Really Enough Time For Reliable Classroom Observations?
Atlanta Journal Constitution, GA, January 19, 2013

A middle school teacher I admired for her innovation pulled me aside once to tell me she was leaving the district. Her tendency to stray from the script put her at odds with the new principal.

Legislation May Prompt Charter For Cobb School District
Marietta Daily Journal, GA, January 21, 2013

Cobb’s school board is eyeing a state bill that would require school districts to apply for charter system status or be deemed one of two performance-based systems.

Backed by State Money, Georgia Scholarships Go to Schools Barring Gays
New York Times, NY, January 21, 2013

As the nation works its way through the debate over vouchers and other alternatives to traditional public education funding, a quieter battle over homosexuality, religious education and school tax money is under way in Georgia.

HAWAII

Charities Help Guide Charters On Better School Leadership
Star Advertiser, HI, January 20, 2013

As Hawaii’s charter schools adjust to a new law demanding more accountability, they are getting a helping hand from a coalition of charities led by the Chamberlin Family Foundation, which was created by two Roosevelt High School alumni.

ILLINOIS

A Victory For Charter Freedom
Chicago Tribune, IL, January 21, 2013

In 2011 we told you about the high-profile legal fuss kicked up when some teachers at the Chicago Math and Science Academy, a North Side charter school, said they wanted to join a union.

INDIANA

Do Indiana Charter Schools Measure Up, Outperform?
South Bend Tribune, IN, January 21, 2013

Elijah Magruder attended three schools before he found one where he finally feels at home.

Branstad: Education Reform Must Precede More State Aid
Indianapolis Star, IN, January 19, 2013

Gov. Terry Branstad said Friday he’s willing to consider additional state aid for schools on top of what he has proposed for education reform. He’s still insisting, however, that legislators make decisions on reform first.

LOUISIANA

Teachers’ Groups Disagree On Changes
The Advocate, LA, January 21, 2013

While two unions are vehemently opposed to the new teacher evaluations, a third teachers’ group is embracing the overhaul and instructing educators on how it works.

MASSACHUSETTS

Gloucester Schools Welcome 98 Charter Students After GCACS Closes
Cape Ann Beacon, MA, January 20, 2013

While it’s not uncommon for a student or two to transfer to a new school during the middle of the school year, the closing of the Gloucester Community Arts Charter School on Jan. 9 required the handling of this transition on a whole different level.

MARYLAND

No Single Way To Advance Student Achievement
Capital Gazette, MD, January 21, 2013

Recently released data that tracks student academic success at every school across the state has generated a considerable amount of discussion about the value of standardized testing and the methodology by which schools are held accountable.

MICHIGAN

Beating The Odds: Three Oaks Charter School Thriving After Closure Threat
Muskegon Chronicle, MI, January 20, 2013

On the verge of closure nearly three years ago, Three Oaks Public School Academy has turned itself around, winning a new eight-year charter school contract as well as special recognition from the state for its improved test scores.

Jackson Community College Board Should Say No To Proposed Charter School
Jackson Citizen Patriot, MI, January 20, 2013

The Jackson Preparatory and Early College charter school sounds like an excellent idea. But not now. Not in Jackson County.

Michigan’s Charters Make The Grade
Detroit News, MI, January 20, 2013

A study showcasing student growth at Michigan charter schools indicates state is on the right track

Group Gives Michigan ‘A’ For Support Of Charter Schools
Detroit News, MI, January 18, 2013

Michigan earned an “A” for its charter school laws, according to a report card issued this week by the Center for Education Reform.

MISSISSIPPI

If State Can’t Fund MAEP, How Will It Fund Charter Schools?
Hattiesburg American, MS, January 19, 2013

As a school board member in the Lumberton School District, I feel compelled to ask a question regarding charter schools.

NEW HAMPSHIRE

Charter Schools Snared In N.H. Budget Process
Exeter News-Letter, NH, January 20, 2013

A proposed Exeter area regional charter school that aspired to open in September continues to find itself at mercy of the state.

NEW JERSEY

Some Newark Schools Succeed With Most Troubled Students, Data Shows
Star Ledger, NJ, January 20, 2013

Many of the children who attend Miller Street School in Newark’s South Ward walk to school through scarred and troubled neighborhoods. They pass rusted auto-body shops, people dealing drugs and transactions for sex before their school day even begins.

NEW MEXICO

End To Golden Parachutes One Of Many School Reform Bills This Year
Las Cruces Sun-News, NM, January 19, 2013

Golden parachutes are draining money from New Mexico’s classrooms, says a state legislator who wants to limit school superintendents to one-year contracts.

NEW YORK

Better Learning Costs Money
Albany Times Union, NY, January 21, 2013

Gov. Andrew Cuomo has endorsed a number of initiatives proposed by his education reform commission, on which I serve — including full-day prekindergarten, extended learning time, community schools for high-needs districts and more effective teacher recruitment.

Department Of Education Chancellor Dennis Walcott: I Blame UFT Boss For Teachers Evaluations Disaster
New York Daily News, NY, January 19, 2013

Teachers union and the department of Education have failed to reach an agreement of evaluations. The impasse cost the city at least $450 million in government funding.

King Flunks On Teacher Evaluations
New York Daily News, NY, January 20, 2013

New York City’s schoolchildren face dire consequences after Mayor Bloomberg and teachers union President Michael Mulgrew missed the deadline for negotiating a teacher evaluation system.

NORTH CAROLINA

Triangle Faces Wave Of New Charter Schools
News & Observer, NC, January 20, 2013

Nearly 30 new charter schools could open in the Triangle in 2014, shaking up the region’s public-education landscape and providing additional competition for local school districts.

Bill Would Make Forsyth County Schools State’s First ‘Charter School District’
Winston-Salem Journal, NC, January 19, 2013

State Rep. Donny Lambeth, R-Forsyth, said he plans to co-sponsor a bill in the N.C. House that would convert the Winston-Salem/Forsyth County Schools to the state’s first charter-school district, aiming to reduce state regulatory control and allow more innovation by administrators and teachers.

OHIO

Cleveland Schools Go Back To Full Days With Extra Reading And Math Classes For Struggling Schools
Cleveland Plain Dealer, OH, January 20, 2013

Cleveland students will go back to full school days Tuesday, with most of the music, art, gym and library classes brought back after voters passed a new school tax in November.

School Rules Guide Whistle-Blowers
Columbus Dispatch, OH, January 21, 2013

Amid a statewide investigation into data manipulation in schools, districts are creating rules to guide employees if they want to report workers who violate laws or ethics.

PENNSYLVANIA

Parents Who Waited For Penn Alexander Kindergarten Spots Vow To Fight On
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, January 21, 2013

Parents who had prepared to camp out for four days to register their children for kindergarten in one of the city’s best neighborhood schools have packed up their tents and gone home.

Souderton Charter School Growing
The Intelligencer, PA, January 20, 2013

As the Souderton Area School District goes through the controversial process of shuttering one of its seven elementary schools due to a downward trend in enrollment, one small charter school in its borders is making plans to grow.

TENNESSEE

Haslam Addresses School Vouchers Issues
The Memphis Daily News, TN, January 21, 2013

Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam says the third year of significant education reform legislation in the Tennessee General Assembly will include vouchers but added that “ultimately our efforts in Tennessee are going to be around the vast majority of kids that are in public schools.”

UTAH

Utah Praised For Abundance Of Charter School Options
Salt Lake Tribune, UT, January 18, 2013

Utah ranks 11th in the nation when it comes to charter school programs, according to a new national study.

WISCONSIN

Three Ex-GOP Speakers Now Lobby For School Choice
Janesville Gazette, WI, January 21, 2013

Several former Assembly speakers looked on Jan. 7 as the 75th speaker, Republican Rep. Robin Vos, was elected to lead that half of the Legislature.

Democracy In The Way of Vouchers
The Oshkosh Northwestern, WI, January 20, 2013

Leave it to Sen. Mike Ellis to hit the nail on the head: The expansion of school vouchers is a non-starter in northeast Wisconsin. In our view, such is the case across Wisconsin. The Senate president, in typically blunt language, called last week for local referendum votes on any expansion of the state’s school voucher program outside of Milwaukee and Racine.

Deciding Voucher Issues Is Job of Legislators
Wisconsin State Journal, WI, January 20, 2013

When it comes to whether this or any other state should provide students with taxpayer-funded vouchers to attend private school, there is no shortage of opinion, study, vested interest, ideology and passion to help guide our elected officials.

ONLINE LEARNING

Views Differ On Virtual Education
Boston Globe, MA, January 19, 2013

A new state law opening the way for more virtual schools in Massachusetts is drawing mixed reactions from area school officials, with some welcoming it and others voicing concern.

Many Alle-Kiski School Districts Challenge Private Charter, Cyber Schools
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, PA, January 20, 2013

Many Alle-Kiski school districts are tired of footing the bill for students who decide to go to private charter and cyber schools, so they‘re fighting back.

State Trend Of Cyberschools Opening Learning Centers Comes To Lehigh Valley
Lehigh Valley Express-Times, PA, January 19, 2013

Achievement House Cyber Charter School has opened a learning center in South Bethlehem that the school says is the first of its kind in the Lehigh Valley.

New Trend In Classroom Instruction
Northwest Arkansas News, AR, January 19, 2013

Some teachers in Fayetteville and other districts are using a new model called flipped instruction. They said it helps students keep up with classroom work and provides more time for concentrated work exercises in the classroom.

Share Parent Power

Share this link with other parents to let them know about Parent Power!

You can also download and print a copy of this cartoon to pass out and share with other parents in person.

Daily Headlines for January 18, 2013

NEWSWIRE IS BACK! Click here for the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else, spiced with a dash of irreverence, from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

NATIONAL COVERAGE

In Pursuit of Safety, Schools’ Paths Diverge
Wall Street Journal, January 18, 2013

A month after a gunman massacred 20 students in Newtown, Conn., school districts nationwide are struggling with safety issues and taking widely divergent approaches.

FROM THE STATES

ARKANSAS

Judge Finds No Violations Of School Deal
Northwest Arkansas News, AR, January 18, 2013

U.S. District Judge D. Price Marshall Jr. on Thursday ruled that the establishment of nearly a dozen state-approved charter schools in Pulaski County did not violate a 1989 desegregation settlement terms between the state and the three Pulaski County school districts.

Billionaires’ Bill Filed To Strip State Education Board Of Charter School Review
Arkansas Times Blog, AR, January 17, 2013

The long-expected bill originating from the Billionaire Boys Club to strip the state Board of Education of its oversight of charter school applications and performance was filed today.

CALIFORNIA

Charter Schools See Largest Boom Since Their Inception 20 Years Ago
Daily Breeze, CA, January 17, 2013

Charter schools across the United States are proliferating and expanding at a record pace, with the trend particularly pronounced in California and Los Angeles County.

Green Dot Charter Group To Reorganize Locke High
Los Angeles Times, CA, January 18, 2013

Green Dot hopes the changes will counter the slumping academic performance of incoming ninth-grade students.

Parents At Troubled School Take Reform Petitions To LAUSD
Los Angeles Times, CA, January 18, 2013

After about 100 parents from 24th Street Elementary drop off the parent trigger petitions, Supt. John Deasy pledges to work with them to improve the school.

CONNECTICUT

Editorial Wrong About Charter Schools
Stamford Advocate, CT, January 17, 2013

Your recent editorial “Charter School Push Fails the Math Test” (Jan. 14) ignores the evidence and distorts the facts about public charter schools. Charters are publicly funded schools that cannot pick and choose who gets in. Every child is free to enroll in a charter school. When there are more students applying to enroll than seats available, a lottery is held.

DELAWARE

4 New Charter Schools Seek OK
News Journal, DE, January 18, 2013

Four new charter schools were proposed to the state Department of Education.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Chancellor Kaya Henderson Names 15 D.C. Schools On Closure List
Washington Post, DC, January 17, 2013

More than one in 10 D.C. public schools will close as part of a plan Chancellor Kaya Henderson put forth Thursday, a retrenchment amid budget pressures, low enrollment and growing competition from public charter schools.

FLORIDA

Clay School Board Turns Down Charter School Application
Florida Times Union, FL, January 17, 2013

The Clay County School Board voted 4-1 to deny the charter school application of Orange Park Performing Arts Academy because it failed to meet state standards for opening.

Pasco Schools Not Equipped For New Teacher Evaluation System
Tampa Bay Times, FL, January 18, 2013

While the legal battle is under way over a controversial 2011 state law that bases teacher evaluations and pay on student test scores, the Pasco school district is looking at what it would take to implement the law.

GEORGIA

School Board Approves 5-Year Charter Renewal
Cherokee Tribune, GA, January 18, 2013

Along with 13 other charter schools in Georgia, Cherokee Charter Academy received approval Thursday from the state Board of Education for a five-year charter renewal.

State Charter Schools Commission Appointed
GPB, GA, January 17, 2013

The State Board of Education on Thursday appointed a new seven member Charter Schools Commission. Officials hope it will spur creation of charter schools across the state.

ILLINOIS

CPS Principals Will Be Formally Evaluated On Student Academic Growth
Chicago Sun Times, IL, January 17, 2013

Just as evaluations of Chicago Public School teachers are partly based on the test scores of their students, principals also will be formally evaluated as of February on student academic growth, with bonuses going to the ones who thrive, the schools chief announced Thursday.

INDIANA

Pence, GOP Legislators Push Expanding School Vouchers, Pre-Kindergarten To Top Of Agenda
Evansville Courier & Press, IN, January 17, 2013

Expanding Indiana’s voucher system and beginning to fund pre-kindergarten are the central planks of an education legislative agenda being driven by Gov. Mike Pence and House leaders.

IOWA

Senate Democrats Pledge 4% Bump In Aid To Schools
Des Moines Register, IA, January 17, 2013

Iowa Senate Democrats, ignoring a demand from Gov. Terry Branstad, said Thursday that they would approve a 4 percent increase in basic state aid to schools for the coming academic year at a cost of about $135 million.

LOUISIANA

Successful Charters Can Now Open New Schools Without State OK
Times-Picayune, LA, January 17, 2013

The state is making it easier for successful charters to open new schools while tightening financial and management oversight of the charters it approves.

Charter School Could Help Improve Local School System
The Daily News, LA, January 18, 2013

A new era in Bogalusa education will be ushered in with the opening of Northshore Charter School in August. Although no site has been selected, the school is scheduled to welcome kindergarten, first-, second- and ninth-grade students for the 2013-14 school year and is expected to house up to 620 students in a K-12 facility by the 2017-18 school year.

New Orleans’ Graduation Rate Is On The Rise
Times-Picayune, LA, January 18, 2013

In another indication that post-Katrina education reforms are paying off, New Orleans high schools had a better 2011 graduation rate than the state and national average. In city schools, 76.5 percent of students graduated within four years. That was higher than the state average of 70.9 percent and significantly higher than the rates in Jefferson Parish, Baton Rouge and Shreveport, according to an analysis by Educate Now.

MASSACHUSETTS

Patrick’s Education Proposal Should Reform More
Boston Globe, MA, January 18, 2013

In his Wednesday state of the state speech, Governor Patrick claimed his education proposals will help the state prepare for the challenges of the future.

More Charter Schools Sought
Boston Globe, MA, January 18, 2013

A group of charter school advocates, business leaders, and legislators is pushing to abolish a state-imposed cap on the number of charter schools that can operate in Boston and other low-performing school districts, under legislation expected to be filed Friday on Beacon Hill.

MISSISSIPPI

Adopt-A-School Is Making A Difference
Jackson Clarion Ledger, MS, January 18, 2013

Charter schools are proposed as a solution for failing public schools, yet there are ways to strengthen these schools without diverting resources.

NEW JERSEY

School Choice Program Growing With Each Year
New Jersey Herald, NJ, January 17, 2013

Since its inception two years ago, the state’s Interdistrict Public School Choice program has more than doubled.

NEW YORK

NYC, Union Trade Harsh Words Over Plan Impasse
Wall Street Journal, January 18, 2013

The issue of teacher evaluations, which has been contentious around the country, brought New York City and its teachers’ union to an impasse and harsh war of words that has put the city at risk of losing up to $450 million in state aid and grants.

Doomed to Fail
New York Daily News, NY, January 18, 2013

Why teacher evaluation talks fell apart: Because state law gave the union the power to block a deal

No Deal on Teacher Evaluations; City Risks Losing $450 Million
New York Times, NY, January 18, 2013

The Bloomberg administration and New York City’s teachers’ union said Thursday that they had failed to reach a deal on a new system for evaluating 75,000 public school teachers, putting the city into immediate danger of losing out on up to $450 million in state and federal money and raising the possibility of cuts to staff and programs.

Staten Island’s Students Are The Losers As Teachers, City Throw Away $450M
Staten Island Advance, NY, January 18, 2013

As the midnight deadline came and went, nothing had changed.
And that’s bad news for students on Staten Island and in the rest of the city.

The City’s School Bus Strike Hits Disabled Students The Hardest
New York Daily News, NY, January 17, 2013

With several subways missing elevator access and cabs lacking adequate storage space for wheelchairs, parents of special needs children already grow frustrated.

OHIO

Yost Seeks Periodic Head Count Of Students
Columbus Dispatch, OH, January 18, 2013

Conducting official head counts of schoolchildren several times a year would discourage the “scrubbing” of student data, the state auditor says.

PENNSYLVANIA

Philadelphia School Reform Commission Votes Not To Renew City’s Oldest Charter School
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, January 18, 2013

The Philadelphia School Reform Commission said Thursday night that the district’s oldest charter school did not deserve to be renewed because of low test scores and financial problems.

School-Closing Arguments Highlight SRC Meeting
Philadelphia Daily News, PA, January 18, 2013

MORE THAN 70 people signed up to air their grievances at the School Reform Commission meeting Thursday night, an unusually high number reflective of the controversy surrounding the district’s decision to close 37 schools.

TENNESSEE

Answers Needed On School Voucher Plan
Knoxville News Sentinel, TN, January 18, 2013

Gov. Bill Haslam announced Monday that he will be pushing for vouchers for low-income students in “lower-performing schools.”

TEXAS

School Board Opposes Vouchers
Victoria Advocate, TX, January 17, 2013

The Victoria school board does not support private school vouchers.
On Thursday, the board voted unanimously to approve a resolution opposing the bill that is pending with the state Legislature.

Students In Low-Performing Schools Have Way Out — Maybe
Star-Telegram, TX, January 17, 2013

It has been argued for decades that no student should be “trapped” in a bad school, and in 1995 the Texas Legislature passed a law to provide students so ensnared a way out.

VIRGINIA

Va. Senate Panel Endorses 4 Schools Bills
Richmond Times-Dispatch, VA, January 17, 2013

Gov. Bob McDonnell’s attempt to leave a legacy of education reform as his four-year term winds down received a modest boost from a Senate committee Thursday.

WISCONSIN

GOP Senator To Push For Voucher Vote
Herald Times Reporter, WI, January 17, 2013

The president of the Wisconsin Senate said Thursday that he will oppose any expansion of school vouchers unless local residents vote on such a move, a proposal that could jeopardize growth of the program outside of Milwaukee and Racine.

Milwaukee School Choice Beats The Alternative
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, WI, January 17, 2013

Education expert Diane Ravitch wrote in a Jan. 11 op-ed that Milwaukee should abandon its long-running school choice programs involving private and public charter schools and instead concentrate all education resources on a single, monopolistic public school system.

ONLINE LEARNING

NW Area Oks Cyber, Charter School Pact
Wilkes Barre Times-Leader, PA, January 18, 2013

In addition to approving a new teachers contract at Wednesday night’s meeting, the Northwest Area School Board entered into a contract with Virtual Learning Network to provide cyber and charter school curriculums that will coincide with those of the district.

Medina High Students Are Making History As Blended Learning Program Produces Website, App Bringing City’s Heritage Into Digital Age
Sun Star Courier, OH, January 17, 2013

Students enrolled in a blended educational course at Medina High School presented an app and website that is all student-built to City Council Monday night.

Oklahoma Supreme Court Refuses To Take Up Legal Challenge To Charter School, Textbook Law
The Oklahoman, OK, January 18, 2013

The Oklahoma Supreme Court has refused to hear a legal challenge to a law passed last year that authorized a statewide virtual charter school and $30 million for textbooks for public schools.

Montana Digital Academy Picking Up Steam
Billings Gazette, MT, January 18, 2013

The obvious appeal — taking a required math class in your pajamas — is trumped only by the fact that almost any class, from Chinese to oceanography, is available upon request.

School Choice is — and was — Bipartisan

January 17, 2013

We’ve got a treat for you this Thursday afternoon with this blast from the past letter we found in our archives and couldn’t help but share, especially with National School Choice Week only 10 days away and an Arkansas Senator just yesterday proposing new school choice legislation :

(click on the image to see a copy of the actual letter)


 

October 18, 1990

Representative Polly Williams
State Capitol
Room 18 East
P. O. Box 8953
Madison, Wisconsin 53708

Dear Polly:

I read Don Lambro’s recent column about your version of the school choice bill in Milwaukee. I am fascinated by that proposal and am having my staff analyze it. I’m concerned that the traditional Democratic Party establishment has not given you more encouragement. The visionary is rarely embraced by the status quo.

Keep up the good work.

Sincerely,
Bill Clinton

Daily Headlines for January 17, 2013

NEWSWIRE IS BACK! Click here for the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else, spiced with a dash of irreverence, from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

NATIONAL COVERAGE

Teachers Unions Support Obama’s School Safety Initiatives
Washington Post Blog, DC, January 16, 2013

The nation’s two main teachers unions, representing about 4.5 million educators and school personnel, support Obama’s initiatives regarding school safety.

FROM THE STATES

ARKANSAS

School Choice Law Hits Appellate Court
KARK, AR, January 16, 2013

Arkansas’ school choice law is in the limelight in St. Louis. The 8th District Court of Appeals is hearing the case after a federal judge in Hot Springs declared the law unconstitutional.

CALIFORNIA

Help School Districts By Letting Them Raise Their Own Tax Revenue
Los Angeles Times, CA, January 16, 2013

To do so, the state Legislature would need to reduce the voter threshold needed for levying parcel taxes from two-thirds to 55%.

CONNECTICUT

4 New City Charter Schools Proposed
New Haven Independent, CT, January 16, 2013

After two more young men connected to his congregation died of gun violence, Rev. Eldren D. Morrison concluded the need for a new charter school in Dixwell and Newhallville had grown all the more urgent: “the need is between life and death.”

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

D.C. Principals, Georgetown Launch Leadership Program
Washington Post, DC, January 16, 2013

A group of 25 principals of D.C. public schools this week began a master’s-degree program at , part of an effort to improve the quality of leadership in the city’s schools.

D.C. Leads Nation In Strength Of Charter School Laws, Report Says
Washington Post, DC, January 16, 2013

The District leads the nation in terms of the strength of its public charter school laws and their implementation, according to a new report issued Wednesday by a national group that supports charter schools.

FLORIDA

State, Teachers Union Spar Over Merit Pay
Tallahassee Democrat, FL, January 17, 2013

After two hours of arguments, Judge John Cooper seemed certain of one thing: It will likely be up to an appellate judge or the state Supreme Court to decide ultimate fate of Florida’s law tying teacher pay to student test scores.

Proposed Clay Charter School Faces Denial
Florida Times Union, FL, January 16, 2013

A proposed performing arts charter school in Orange Park has failed for the second time to meet state application standards required to open, according to two reviews by Clay County school district officials.

GEORGIA

Dekalb School Board Tries To Hang On To Jobs
Atlanta Journal-Constitution, GA, January 17, 2013

Members of the DeKalb County school board will ask the state school board Thursday to let them keep their jobs.

INDIANA

School Standards Divide Hoosiers
The Journal Gazette, IN, January 17, 2013

A divide over new national education standards hit the Indiana Senate on Wednesday, with the education panel hearing four hours of testimony criticizing and supporting the measure.

LOUISIANA

Muhammad: Charter Would Be ‘Damaging’
Monroe News Star, LA, January 17, 2013

Monroe City School Board President Verbon Muhammad believes that losing Neville High School to the state’s Board of Elementary and Secondary Education for oversight of its charter would be “further damaging” to the school district.

John White Scores 3.15 Of 4 In First Year As State Superintendent
Times-Picayune, LA, January 16, 2013

State Superintendent John White may push controversial programs, but he’s largely pleasing his bosses, the state Board of Elementary and Secondary Education. White earned a preliminary score of 3.15 out of 4 on his first performance review Wednesday.

Activist Says Creationism Is Taught In 20 Louisiana Private Schools That Could Enroll Voucher Students
Times-Picayune, LA, January 16, 2013

Louisiana anti-creationism advocate Zack Kopplin has launched a national database of 300 schools that are partly publicly funded and teach creationism, the belief that all living organisms originate from divine creation, as in the biblical account. The site,creationistvouchers.com, lists 20 such schools in Louisiana.

Time To Reform Public Schools
The Daily Advertiser, LA, January 17, 2013

It looks like the school voucher program is going to be declared unconstitutional.

MARYLAND

Charter Evaluation A Flawed Measure Of Baltimore Montessori’s Success
Baltimore Sun, MD, January 16, 2013

I am writing to share one perspective on the charter renewal process and provide more information about Baltimore Montessori Public Charter School (“Panel urges cutting ties to 6 schools,” Jan. 11). We set out to offer a personalized approach to teaching and learning for kids in Baltimore. How? By embracing the whole child, providing inspiring and challenging work within a very diverse and supportive community.

MASSACHUSSETTS

Charter Students Join New Schools
Boston Globe, MA, January 17, 2013

In the wake of last week’s closing of the Gloucester Community Arts Charter School, more than 20 teachers received pink slips, while parents scrambled to find new schools for their children.

Sturgis Charter School Holds Lottery For Next Year
Bourne Courier, MA, January 16, 2013

Sturgis Charter Public School selected 180 9th graders for the 2013-14 school year in a lottery last week. The school received 563 Grade 9 applications, an increase of 35 percent over the previous year.

Achievement Gap Plan Includes “Hard Work”
North Adams Transcript, MA, January 17, 2013

The school district’s efforts to close its achievement gap is being handled in an egalitarian manner: Everyone in each building, from students on up, must work harder, officials say.

MICHIGAN

Judge To Hear Arguments In Dispute Between DPS, Emergency Financial Manager
Detroit News, MI, January 17, 2013

A judge will hear oral arguments Feb. 20 in a dispute between the Detroit school board and Emergency Financial Manager Roy Roberts over control of academics and finances in the state’s largest district.

Snyder’s Education Push Puts Spotlight On Lansing Schools
Lansing State Journal, MI, January 17, 2013

If Lansing educators thought they dodged a bullet when an education reform measure died last month in the Legislature, Gov. Rick Snyder gave them new reason Wednesday to be worried.

MINNESOTA

Minnesota Schools Still Separate, Still Unequal
Twin City Daily Planet, MN, January 16, 2013

Minnesota was the first state in the nation to allow charter schools in 1991. While still technically public schools, charter schools are only subject to a selection of the rules and regulations that apply to most public schools.

MISSISSIPPI

Miss. Senate Approves Expanded Charter School Bill
Sun Herald, MS, January 16, 2013

A bill to expand charter schools in Mississippi easily cleared the Senate on Wednesday, and attention shifts to the House for the second year.

Charter Schools Pass Senate
Desoto Times, MS, January 17, 2013

Charter school legislation passed the Mississippi Senate Wednesday 31-17, with one DeSoto County state senator voting for it and the other against it.

NEW HAMPSHIRE

State Board Of Education Panel Reaffirms No New Charter School Dollars Available
Union Leader, NH, January 17, 2013

The chairman of the state Board of Education on Wednesday reaffirmed the board’s ban on approving any new charter schools in New Hampshire until the Legislature provides additional funding.

Academy For Science And Design Charter Renewed For Five Years
Nashua Telegraph, NH, January 17, 2013

Students and staff at the Academy of Science and Design can breathe easier, after the state Board of Education voted to renew its charter for another five years.

NEW MEXICO

School Choice Improves Educational Outcomes
Las Cruces Sun-News, NM, January 17, 2013

School Choice Week is right around the corner. This year’s celebration includes a special cross-country “whistle stop” train tour with stops in 14 cities from coast-to-coast, including Albuquerque. Our celebration takes place on Saturday, Jan. 26 at the Albuquerque Museum in Old Town. More information is available on the Rio Grande Foundation’s website. Please come out to support school choice in New Mexico!

NEW YORK

Deadline Imminent For City Teacher Evaluation System
NY 1, NY, January 1, 2013

Today is the deadline for the city to figure out how to rate its school teachers, but as of last night there is still no deal in place between the city Department of Education and the United Federation of Teachers.

A Stubborn Union Blocks Reform
New York Daily News, NY, January 17, 2013

If Gov. Cuomo makes good on his promise, New York City schools will forfeit hundreds of millions of dollars in state aid Friday — all because the United Federation of Teachers and the Department of Education will have failed by Thursday’s midnight deadline to agree to a plan to evaluate teachers on student performance and other important measures.

Teachers Union President Michael Mulgrew Is About To Cost The City Millions In State Aid
New York Daily News, NY, January 17, 2013

With hours to go before Gov. Cuomo’s deadline for school districts and their unions to negotiate and have approved rigorous teacher evaluation systems, talks between the city and the United Federation of Teachers are dead in the water.

20% Or More Bad Teachers Clustered At 14 Brooklyn Schools, Study Finds
New York Daily News, NY, January 16, 2013

They’re the unfortunate 14 — Brooklyn public schools with 20% or more bad teachers.

School Bus Strike In New York City Enters 2nd Day
Associated Press, January 17, 2013

A standoff between striking school bus drivers and aides looking for job protections and a city administration that says they just can’t have it has the potential to go on for some time, observers said, as parents scrambled for a second day to figure out alternatives for tens of thousands of students who need to get to school.

OHIO

School Reformer Backs Kasich’s Efforts
Columbus Dispatch, OH, January 17, 2013

A national education leader who has the ears of Gov. John Kasich and other Ohio GOP leaders says the state’s education system has improved, and she hopes this year to help push additional reforms through the General Assembly.

OKLAHOMA

Oklahoma City Public Schools Officials Outline Reasons For Rejecting Charter Schools
The Oklahoman, OK, January 17, 2013

Oklahoma City Public Schools officials have announced why two charter school applications were rejected. The school district’s attorney declined to release the information after the board voted to decline the applications.

PENNSLYVANIA

Hard-Hit Districts Push Back Against Charter Schools
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, PA, January 17, 2013

Western Pennsylvania school districts that are losing students and money to charter schools are fighting back.

Recovery Chief Says Merger Not An Option For Duquesne
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, PA, January 17, 2013

A merger of Duquesne City School District with a neighboring district is no longer being considered, state-appointed chief recovery officer Paul B. Long told a forum on Wednesday.

Pittsburgh Public Schools Recommends Granting Hazelwood Charter School Request
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, January 16, 2013

A Pittsburgh Public Schools review committee has recommended the school board grant a request from Propel Schools to open a charter in Hazelwood this fall, but it is not clear the board would agree when it votes Jan. 23.

Championship Academy Plan Draws Criticism From City Schools Administration
The York Dispatch, PA, January 17, 2013

Championship Academy of Distinction had the second half of its hearing with the York City School Board on Wednesday. The hearing was the board’s last chance to ask questions of founder Cynthia Dotson, who wants to create a fitness and sports-themed charter school based at the YWCA.

TENNESSEE

Rejected Memphis Charter School Operators Plead Their Cases To The State
Commercial Appeal, TN, January 16, 2013

Charter school operators previously rejected by the Unified Shelby County Schools board took their cases to the state Wednesday, explaining why they are qualified to run schools and why the local decision to deny the charters should be overturned.

Giving Students Attending Failing School More Charter School Options Is Key, No Matter Who Approves Charters
Commercial Appeal, TN, January 17, 2013

It looks like the Tennessee General Assembly this session will consider legislation challenging the ability of local school boards to manage their own affairs.

TEXAS

Area School Districts Opposed To Vouchers
Weatherford Democrat, TX, January 17, 2013

As superintendents and school board presidents representing the Aledo, Azle, Brock, Garner, Millsap, Paradise, Peaster, Poolville, Santo, Springtown, and Weatherford independent school districts we know that our public schools are under attack.

ONLINE LEARNING

Cheboygan Area Schools Starting Virtual School In Late January
Cheboygan News, MI, January 17, 2013

Cheboygan Area Schools is taking a preemptive step in the future of education, announcing plans for a virtual school that will begin serving students later in January.

‘Flipped Classroom’ Offers One Solution To Homework Overload
Beacon News, IL, January 16, 2013

Everyone hates homework. Students complain about doing it, teachers hate correcting it, and parents feel helpless when they lack the expertise to help with it.

Colorado Virtual Academy Answers Tough Questions on Operations, Academic Performance
KUNC, CO, January 17, 2013

Officials at Colorado Virtual Academy were in the hot seat Wednesday night as the school’s authorizing district questioned everything from its academic performance to its relationship with the for-profit management company, K12 Inc.

Mississippi Senate approves expanded charter school bill

by Jeff Amy, Associated Press
Sun Herald
January 17, 2013

A bill to expand charter schools in Mississippi easily cleared the Senate on Wednesday, and attention shifts to the House for the second year.

In a 31-17 vote, the bill had two Democratic supporters but no Republican opponents. The vote came after more than three hours of debate, a day after Senate Bill 2189 was introduced and passed by the Senate Education Committee.

Charter schools are public schools that agree to meet certain standards in exchange for freedom from regulations. Mississippi has a charter school law that allows a small number of its schools to convert to charters, but none has done so.

Wednesday, the Center for Education Reform, a pro-charter group based in Washington, called Mississippi’s law the “worst charter law in the country.”

Proponents said charter schools can improve achievement in Mississippi. “I think more than anything this is about closing the achievement gap in our state,” said Senate Education Committee Chairman Gray Tollison. The Oxford Republican wrote SB 2189.

Opponents, though, fear charters will weaken traditional schools by skimming motivated students and money. “The overriding concern is what is going to happen to school districts when you start separating students out,” said Sen. Hob Bryan, D-Amory.

Coast officials weigh in

Superintendents in South Mississippi had mixed reactions to the Senate’s bill.

Wayne Rodolfich, superintendent in Pascagoula, said he thinks the state should concentrate on improving the failing schools rather than open more schools.

“If you have a magic way of improving education, give us all that flexibility,” he said. “Let all of us do it.”

He also is concerned about money for current programs.

“Funding is going to be a major issue,” he said. “I think it’s important that we don’t destroy existing programs for charter schools. You can’t underfund education and then expect it to excel.”

Arthur McMillan, superintendent in Biloxi, agreed, adding a district shouldn’t open a new school for a small percentage of students.

“If charter schools work and you have a failing school, why not turn the whole school into a charter school?” he said.

Gulfport Superintendent Glen East said he would be willing to try charter schools if they would help students in failing schools.

“I’m not opposed to anything that’s going to help children,” he said. “If we can help children who want to be in an outstanding school, then let’s do it. I’m tired of being 50th (Mississippi’s ranking among the nation’s schools).”

The bill would give districts rated A or B a veto over whether charters can be put there, but those rated C and lower districts wouldn’t get a veto.

Most school districts in South Mississippi wouldn’t be required to allow a charter school to open under the bill.

In South Mississippi, it would apply to three school districts: Moss Point, Pearl River County and Picayune.

The state Department of Education has said it would like to see the rule apply only to districts that received a D or an F.

Governance, financing

A seven-member board would approve charter schools and oversee them, with three members appointed by the governor, three members appointed by the lieutenant governor and one member appointed by the state superintendent.

Students would be allowed to cross district lines to enroll in charter schools, and a local tax contribution from the home district would go with charter students, as well as state aid.

On to the state House

No House bills regarding charter schools had yet been introduced Wednesday evening. But many House members favor allowing C-rated districts to have vetoes as well, and House Speaker Philip Gunn, R-Clinton, has said the House bill imposes a limit of 15 charters a year.

Lt. Gov. Tate Reeves, also a Republican, fought to deny vetoes to C districts last year. He said after the vote Wednesday it is important to have a law “that allows for the largest number of students possible having a public charter school option.” But he didn’t rule out a compromise.

Supporters Wednesday included two black Democrats, Sampson Jackson of Preston and Willie Simmons of Cleveland. Simmons said Tollison made changes that won his vote. He said the charter school law might dovetail with Simmons’ proposal to create a model school in Sunflower County to bolster parent involvement and social services for students.

“It will give them an option at the local level if they desire to utilize the charter school option,” Simmons said after the vote.

Changes from last year

Among the changes Tollison made between 2012 and 2013:

– Requiring applicants to show evidence of “adequate” community support and to analyze the impact on other public and private schools in an area.

– Explicitly banning private school conversions or new charter schools created by private school groups.

– Requiring charters to serve a proportion of under-served students at least 80 percent as large as the share of under-served students in the charter’s home district. The bill defines under-served as students with low family incomes, poor academic performance, special education needs or limited fluency in English.

– Ordering that the authorizing board must close a charter school if it is rated F for two consecutive years or if the school’s performance is the bottom 20 percent of all schools statewide when the five-year contract runs out. Charters could get reprieves for “exceptional” circumstances.

– Requiring 75 percent of teachers to be certified, and the remaining quarter to earn certification within three years. Last year, the Senate bill required only 50 percent of teachers to be certified.

Tuesday, senators amended the bill to require a shutdown after two years of F ratings. Tollison’s draft had said three. The Education Committee amended the bill Tuesday to ban schools that operate entirely online.

Hard-hit districts push back against charter schools

by Daveen Rae Kurutz
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review
January 17, 2013

Western Pennsylvania school districts that are losing students and money to charter schools are fighting back.

The Penn Hills school board this week approved spending $3,500 a month for two years of advertising on TV and the Internet. Thirty-second ads will promote the Penn Hills Senior High School that opened last month.

The neighboring Woodland Hills school board awarded a $13,000 contract on Wednesday to develop infomercials to air on public access television.

Districts traditionally have not advertised schools, but their charter-school counterparts have, attracting a growing number of students.

Woodland Hills will pay $13.9 million — nearly 17 percent of its annual budget — to charter schools this year to educate more than 1,150 children who live in the district, the most students among 49 suburban districts the Tribune-Review surveyed. About 22 percent of eligible students there go to charter schools. Penn Hills is sending 787 students to charter schools at a cost of $8.1 million.

“It‘s cost us personnel. It‘s cost us programs,” said Tara Reis, a Woodland Hills board member and parent. “When you see these kinds of numbers, it‘s staggering. That‘s why we don‘t have reading specialists or an after-school tutoring program or pre-K programs anymore.”

Since the Legislature approved charter schools in 1997, 175 have opened statewide. Sixteen are online only. The charters are privately operated but funded by tuition payments from districts.

Supporters say they offer a better education than traditional public schools.

“I feel like a charter school gives us public education with a private-school feel,” said Ivelisse Torres of Penn Hills, whose daughter, Chloe, attends first grade at Imagine Penn Hills Charter School of Entrepreneurship, which opened in 2012.

Districts such as Woodland Hills are fighting reputations for low test scores and violence.

“The parent perspective is that the environment (in the school district) isn‘t conducive for the child,” said Bob Fayfich, executive director of the Pennsylvania Coalition of Public Charter Schools. “There‘s violence in the school, not a focus on learning.”

Reis said Woodland Hills needs to highlight that the district and high school met minimum test score levels. Its infomercials would include a five-minute piece outlining positive things happening in the district; two one-minute spots sharing student experiences and alumni perspectives; and several 30-second ads themed “Woodland Hills … where diversity works.”

Butch Santicola, spokesman for the Pennsylvania State Education Association, the state‘s largest public teachers‘ union, said districts “have sat back and been in defensive mode.”

“Charter schools are a game-changer, no doubt,” said Joseph Domaracki, interim associate dean of the College of Educational Technology at Indiana University of Pennsylvania. “Public schools have to do more to maintain their populations. It‘s a reality.”

Districts responded slowly. Some started cyber programs.

A group of Westmoreland County districts offers courses through e-Academy, a cyber program the Intermediate Unit began. About 600 students participate, including 30 at Norwin‘s Center for 21st Century Learners. Some take traditional and cyber classes, said Tracy McNelly, Norwin‘s assistant superintendent of secondary education.

“What districts are seeing is that it‘s sort of stopping the bleeding,” said Allie Arendas, distance learning specialist for Westmoreland Intermediate Unit.

This year at Quaker Valley schools in the Sewickley area, more students enrolled in the district‘s QV e-Learning program than in charter schools.

“I don‘t know that I have a crystal ball, but competition and choice seem to be the rule of the day,” said Quaker Valley Superintendent Joseph Clapper. “Public school districts, in my opinion, shouldn‘t shy away from that.”

Districts asked state lawmakers for help. A bill to create a commission to study charter school funding passed the Senate but stalled in the House last year.

Sen. Jim Brewster, D- McKeesport, who publicly supported Propel Schools, acknowledged problems with the charter concept because charters siphon money from public districts.

“Right now, it‘s a feeding frenzy,” he said.

Melissa Hart, a lawyer who as a state senator was among sponsors of the charter school law, said she‘s pleased with their development.

“For some kids, the charters have been a real savior in some areas,” Hart said, noting that “no piece of legislation is perfect.”

“I‘m happy … that parents and families have more freedom on where to send kids without having to pay to send them somewhere. I think that‘s a good thing.”

Making the grade

More than 2 million students attend more than 6,000 public charter schools, according to the Center for Education Reform in Washington.

Its 14th annual Charter School Laws Across the States Ranking and Scorecard concludes that fewer than half of the states can meet the demand for charter schools and state laws must improve to ensure growth and sustainability.

The report ranks Pennsylvania 14th in the nation, giving its law a B grade. Among the nation‘s 43 charter school laws, the center gave four As, nine Bs, 19 Cs, and Ds or Fs to the remaining 11 states.

The center evaluates charter school laws based on their construction and implementation, and whether they ensure quality learning opportunities. To read more: https://2024.edreform.com/in-the-states.

D.C. leads nation in strength of charter school laws, report says

by Lindsay Layton
Washington Post
January 16, 2013

The District leads the nation in terms of the strength of its public charter school laws and their implementation, according to a new report issued Wednesday by a national group that supports charter schools.

The Center for Education Reform released its annual report card, in which it examines and rates the charter school system in every state, and found that less than half the states have good, effective charter school laws.

Charter schools are publicly funded but privately run schools, some of them by for-profit organizations. First created 21 years ago, there are now about 6,000 charter schools across the country, educating roughly 2 million students, according to the center.

The District, where more than 40 percent of public school students attend charters, leads the nation in terms of the amount of financial support given to charters and the amount of autonomy they possess, among other things, the center said. The District was ranked at the top last year as well.

In contrast, Virginia and Maryland were ranked among the worst states in terms of public charter laws and implementation.

The report card is available at www.2024.edreform.com/.

Charters Not Designed to Be Responsive to Parents. Right.

January 16, 2013

Huh? There are lots of ridiculously inaccurate things said about charters but this one takes the cake.

“…charters are often not designed with the focus of being responsive to parents…”

That’s funny. I’m not sure how one attracts parents if they are not responsive, but apparently an academic at NYU — and a member of the NY State Board of Regents — thinks otherwise.

Down in Tennessee, The Cornerstone charter school has been in a struggle with the district where it is also running a failed charter. There are rumors about behaviorable tactics being used in the school, including one teacher who took away kids shoes because they were playing with them.

That’s a pretty stupid thing to do under any circumstance, but it hardly has to do with responsiveness to parents, a hallmark of the charter school concept and for which most schools demonstrate huge parental satisfaction.

Here’s Pedro Noguera‘s full quote:
“The kind of reaction you are seeing is not uncommon. There are many communities where that has occurred,” said Pedro Noguera, executive director of the Metropolitan Center for Urban Education at New York University.

“It’s more likely to happen in charters because charters are often not designed with the focus of being responsive to parents, the community or the culture of
the children.”

Right.