Sign up for our newsletter

Education Needs to be Adapted to the Times

Kara Kerwin
The Easley Progress
February 20, 2014

For being the U.S.’s most-watched live event ever, Super Bowl XLVIII was pretty uninspiring.

What was inspiring, however, was the uplifting ad Microsoft ad featuring former NFL safety and ALS patient Steve Gleason, along with other people with disabilities, using innovative new technologies to make life easier. Gleason’s use of a Microsoft product called the Surface gave him the ability to provide voicing for the commercial in heart-rending fashion.

The ad opens with a simple question on the screen as Gleason (in tech-aided voice-over) asks: “What is technology?” As the answers come, “…it unites us…” “…It inspires us…” “…It has taken us to places we never thought we would go…” emotional scenes of tech in action are shown, including a child running on a pair of prosthetic legs, a deaf woman excitedly using an implant to hear a doctor, and a elderly man once blind now able to use a computer efficiently, exclaiming, “Now I can do whatever I want!” The ad concludes with a simple tagline: ‘Empowering us all.’

It’s an effective promo. Even though a vast majority of us don’t know the technological workings of helping a blind man see, who can argue with the ultimate outcome? It’s common sense, really.

As I add another view to the two million the video already has on YouTube, I catch a classroom — pause, rewind, and instant replay. It must have been just a millisecond’s worth of a clip, but it’s there. A classroom full of students ecstatically shares a lesson with another group of their peers remotely through video chat. “Wow,”I think to myself. “That’s common sense too, right?”

Sadly, America doesn’t treat it as such, at least not in implementation. The concept is agreeable and runs seamlessly with the rest of the ad’s message. For all the first-down tech innovation we apply to our lives’ every facet, we fail to take the education of our nation’s children with us to the end zone. Each generation of our students will have lives more immersed in tech than the last. America’s first-graders were born after the iPhone was released.

“What can it do?” the commercial asks.

Ninth-grader Vincent Zhou, the 2013 U.S. Figure Skating Junior Men’s National Champion, is an online student who one day might be a part of the same Olympic games that are happening now in Sochi, Russia. Vincent is also among the three hundred thousand U.S. students who attended school online last year, and he knows full well what it can do.

Vincent goes to Capistrano Connections Academy in California. Young athletes like Vincent are interested in digital learning, whether wholly online or blended, so they can balance a busy training schedule, just one of many reasons families around the country make the decision to take an alternative approach to education.

Online public schools mix typical class structure with the ease of online learning. With no tuition requirement for most online schools, over thirty states offered full-time online schools in multiple districts, respectively, at the end of 2012. Some online schools belong to a local school district, like Appleton School District in northern Wisconsin. Through online schooling, a student can attend school in Appleton despite living over 100 miles away. No wonder over 60 percent of Americans support digital and blended learning.

Students who graduate from the Ohio Connections Academy, a school authorized by the Ohio Council of Community Schools, receive the exact same diploma as their traditional school peers. Connections is one of a growing number of national educators providing online resources and curriculum to public and private schools across all community demographics.

At Connections, parents and teachers work together to provide several lines of support at home and elsewhere. Schools like Connections provide online portals and digital tools to help students stay organized with everything they need at their fingertips.

Nexus Academy, a blended learning educator with locations across multiple states, uses daily online lectures as students do most of their schoolwork independently, meeting regularly to discuss progress and set unique goals with teachers and parents, through face-to-face meetings and video calls.

Construction for a brand new Wheaton High School is underway in Silver Spring, MD as part of Montgomery County’s new plan to infuse “new innovative strategies” into students’ education. But the innovation that Schools Superintendent Joshua Starr defines as “embracing the new” is in stark contrast to the common sense applications from that Super Bowl commercial. The recognition for the need is there. Will we continue to build new housing for old, tired methods, or will we make education adapt to our students, what they need, and the lives they will live beyond schooling?

Kara Kerwin is President of The Center for Education Reform, a K-12 education policy and advocacy organization based in Washington, D.C.

What Amazon can Teach us About U.S. Education

By Jeanne Allen & Kara Kerwin

You’d never know from the Programme for International Assessment (PISA) that the U.S. was in an era of education reform. On a 1,000-point scale, the U.S. has 481 points in math, behind most other industrialized nations, and reading remains stagnant. Last fall the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) painted a similar picture of stagnation for 4th and 8th graders. From government leaders to heads of major education organizations, just about everyone understands this data poses a problem, but seem unwilling to turn it around.You see it in their newsletters and annual reports; you hear it in speeches when they highlight accomplishments in reaching so many children.

These claims might be valid, if Arne Duncan didn’t weakly preface his PISA remarks with what he called “signs of progress,” within the lagging 2013 NAEP scores.

Diane Ravitch, the most prominent of the go-along-get-along gang, said the outcry over lagging scores was an attempt by Duncan to, “whip up national hysteria about our standing in the international league tables.”

Then there’s Amazon’s Jeff Bezos, who always pushes people and challenges them to new heights. He recently shocked the media (and probably a few government officials) by saying he was contemplating a new Drone-delivery system. It’s no surprise then that he would value charter schools, which he backed in Washington state, that are breaking conventional wisdom about how children learn and what they need early to solve our educational ills.

Imagine Bezos as Secretary of Education:

“So let me get this straight – we’ve spent $300 billion each year on education and we’re still behind on International tests?“

“How many charter schools do we have nationwide, 6,000? How do we get 60,000 in the next 3 years?”

“I won’t attend a meeting or listen to another legislator until we have turned every failing school into a successful provider in public, charter or private sectors.”

In other words, he’d bring in the policy equivalent of a drone.

There have been dents made in the public education monopoly, which is still a centralized, top-down cartel of huge proportion. Buoyed with the opportunity to choose, parents and schools challenged the status quo and gave government leaders a reason to make changes to public schools, teacher evaluation, and  early childhood programs and standards. Such progress was made possible by a competitive market of successful schools of choice, which today serve nearly half of all students living in the Nation’s Capital. When only 30 percent of low-income Americans report satisfaction with their local public school, clearly there’s more work to be done.

Too many people settle for a few points as progress. Few leaders and advocates  know of the hard work that went into creating pockets of success. It’s no wonder only 24 percent of Americans approve of their state legislator’s record on education, according to our recent poll. Those who live where there is progress become content with what’s already been accomplished. They want recognition and are fast becoming the establishment they once sought to depose.

Dennis Van Roekel, head of the nation’s largest teacher union, says PISA results are evidence that teacher evaluations in this country are not working, despite performance-based evaluations are not in place in any substantive way anywhere. Meanwhile, Bezos fired his customer relations VP when he learned that the wait time for phone service was not one minute, which had been reported, but actually more than 4 minutes.

The reason we have poor results is because this nation is not making the changes we have seen succeed on a small scale. The publicly accountable charter schools result in student achievement when they are plentiful, free from rules, regulations, union contracts, are open by choice and have money flowing in equal parts to their coffers. Bill Clinton called for 10,000 just 10 years ago, we only have 6,000, even though charter schools have earned a 73 percent favorability rating with the American people. Vouchers work by giving parents power to control the dollars allocated to provide education to their children, yet  supporters argue whether it will ever be politically or legally feasible to do more, rather than changing the political and legal realities. High standards with high stakes tests work, as evidenced by Massachusetts’ achievement gains. Despite this evidence, there is a backlash fueled by wealthy parents who value their children’s comfort over toughening them up with challenges,

The kids who grew up in the Trophy generation are fast becoming the adults who expect pats on the back for predicting rain not making it.

If only Amazon could do education, too. Bring on the drones.

Jeanne Allen is a Senior Fellow and president emeritus and serves on the Board of Directors of The Center for Education Reform. She is President of The Allen Company and currently writes and speaks regularly all over the country on education and cultural issues.

Kara Kerwin is President of The Center for Education Reform, a K-12 education policy and advocacy organization based in Washington, DC.

Daily Headlines for February 28, 2014

Click here for Newswire, the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else – spiced with a dash of irreverence – from the nation’s leading voice in school reform. 

NATIONAL COVERAGE

School districts look at extended school days, years
USA Today, February 26, 2014
Arranged to include frequent, shorter breaks, year-round calendars could help reduce “summer slide” — the loss of knowledge in the summer that disproportionately affects low-income students.

Teachers Wish More People Would Listen to Them
The Atlantic, February 27, 2014
A new survey asked 20,000 teachers for their views on everything from educational technology to teacher evaluations.

Who Sends Their Kids to Charter Schools?
Pacific Standard Magazine, OR, February 27, 2014
“It’s actually a little bit difficult to talk about because I’m very resentful,” says Mari Mejor, who met with me at a Portland coffee shop to talk about her experiences at Trillium Charter School, which she attended the first two years after it opened.

STATE COVERAGE

CALIFORNIA

Charter schools aren’t necessarily more effective
Letter, Los Angeles Times, CA, February 27, 2014
Re “Teacher tenure comes at expense of children’s education” (Commentary, Feb. 21): Richard Riordan’s and Tim Rutten’s praise of how much better charter schools are than traditional public schools is misleading.

COLORADO

Charter school OK’d, with conditions
Cortez Journal, CO, February 27, 2014
A reluctant Montezuma-Cortez Re-1 school board voted unanimously Tuesday to approve a local charter school application, pending four provisions.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Henderson faces D.C. Council questions about achievement gap, middle schools
Washington Post, DC, February 27, 2014
D.C. Council member David A. Catania recited a litany of data Thursday to illustrate the city’s large and persistent student achievement gaps, using an annual oversight hearing for the school system to ask whether officials are moving quickly enough to improve outcomes for poor and minority children.

Should we fix schools by fixing poverty or fixing teaching?
Washington Post Blog, DC, February 27, 2014
Turnaround for Children aims to improve low-performing schools by addressing the effects of poverty both inside and outside the classroom. This year the organization is working in five DCPS schools and hopes that the school system will incorporate its approach on a broader scale in the future.

FLORIDA

Twin Bills in Florida Legislature Attempt to Halt Common Core
Sunshine State News, FL, February 28, 2014
The State Board of Education may have unanimously passed nearly 100 proposed changes to Common Core State Standards last week, but Florida legislators in both chambers have bills that would stop the implementation of the new standards entirely.

Two Steps Back for Modernizing the Teaching Profession in Florida
Huffington Post, February 27, 2014
The growing national movement to elevate the teaching profession had the rug pulled out from under it this week when Florida released a portion of individual teachers’ performance evaluations to the public as a result of a lawsuit filed by a newspaper. As an educator and an education advocate, we are appalled and find this to be degrading to teachers and the teaching profession.

Vote no on MacDill charter school
Editorial, Tampa Bay Times, FL, February 27, 2014
At every stop so far, the proposal for a charter school at Tampa’s MacDill Air Force Base has been rejected. But organizers now are appealing to the state Board of Education, and why not?

GEORGIA

Georgia House passes several bills to help charter schools
Atlanta Journal Constitution, GA, February 28, 2014
Getting the money to start a charter school in Georgia could be a bit easier if a bill recently passed by the Georgia House of Representatives becomes law.

Let teachers lead reform
Column, Savannah Morning News, GA, February 27, 2014
What’s the difference between an innovation and a fad? Don’t ask America’s education policymakers, because they don’t know. For the answer, you’ll need to look much closer to home.

ILLINOIS

CPS warns employees on testing
Chicago Tribune, IL, February 27, 2014
With a group of parents and some teachers threatening to boycott a state assessment test students are supposed to be given starting Monday, Chicago Public Schools warned principals that employees could face disciplinary action if they interfere with the testing process.

Lawndale should welcome Legacy charter school
Editorial, Chicago Tribune, IL, February 27, 2014
Over the past nine years, Legacy Charter has attracted more and more students to its Lawndale campus. No wonder. Legacy offers a challenging college prep curriculum, teachers who engage students and a reputation for success.

Rock River Valley charter schools see success
Rockford Register Star, IL, February 27, 2014
ROCKFORD – It is a celebratory time for Rockford’s three charter schools. Two are coming up on the renewal of their charter certificates, and two are enjoying expanded facilities after moving into abandoned public schools.

INDIANA

House votes to void Common Core
The Journal Gazette, IN, February 28, 2014
The Indiana House voted 67-26 Thursday to void the Common Core academic standards for the state’s schoolchildren.

MASSACHUSETTS

New Worcester Teacher Evaluations Turn Focus on Student Progress
GoLocal Worcester, MA, February 28, 2014
The latest discussion in judging teacher performance in the state of Massachusetts revolves around so-called “district-determined measures” that evaluate student progress.

School Choice: Is it worth it for Frontier?
The Recorder, MA, February 28, 2014
Since the early 1990s, Frontier Regional School and its feeder schools have allowed out-of-town students to enroll. But now, school leaders are questioning whether participating in the School Choice program is really cost effective.

MICHIGAN

Michigan’s 4-year high school graduation rate rises to nearly 77%
Detroit News, MI, February 28, 2014
Graduation rates in Michigan are increasing, with the statewide four-year graduation rate for the high school class of 2013 reaching 76.96 percent, up 0.7 percentage points from 2012, according to the Michigan Center for Educational Performance and Information.

MISSOURI

School Officials Speak Out On CEI Tax Credits Proposal
The Missourian, MO, February 27, 2014
Local Catholic school officials are excited about the Children’s Education Initiative (CEI) and how it could benefit students in both private and public schools.

NEW HAMPSHIRE

Majority of Nashua school board members back Nashua Teachers Union, support delay of new assessment test
Nashua Telegraph, NH, February 28, 2014
A majority of the members of the Board of Education are supporting a waiver that would allow the city to opt out of the Smarter Balanced Assessment, the exam being rolled out next year to support new Common Core education standards.

NEW JERSEY

Evaluate teachers, not children’s parents
Editorial, Asbury Park Press, NJ, February 27, 2014
Everyone agrees that parental involvement is an important element in a child’s educational success. Parents asking to see homework and checking up on posted test scores online help keep kids on their toes.

NJ Senate approves school closing bill prompted by Newark school reorganization
Star-Ledger, NJ, February 27, 2014
The state Senate approved two measures today prompted by changes proposed by Newark School Superintendent Cami Anderson, including a bill requiring the local school board to approve any school closing.

NEW YORK

Bill slams Eva’s kids
Editorial, New York Daily News, NY, February 28, 2014
After painting charter schools as alien to public education, Mayor de Blasio and Schools Chancellor Carmen Fariña Thursday issued their first serious salvo against the independently run public schools.

Cheating poor kids by choking charters
Opinion, New York Post, NY, February 28, 2014
By unilaterally reversing co-location for several charter schools, including one that has existed since 2008, Mayor de Blasio just snatched the building blocks of upward social mobility from the hands of underprivileged children.

David Bloomfield: Charter school decisions aren’t payback, but good policy
Opinion, New York Daily News, NY, February 28, 2014
People will raise eyebrows that all three of the rejected charter proposals are sponsored by Success Academy. But each had obvious weaknesses: two are elementary schools that would have been housed with large high schools; the other would have resulted in classrooms split between two buildings.

De Blasio Seeks to Halt 3 Charter Schools From
New York Times, NY, February 28, 2014
Mayor Bill de Blasio, seeking to curb the influence of outside providers of education, said on Thursday that he would block three charter schools from using space inside New York City public school buildings.

New York Mayor’s Charter School Decisions Anger Both Sides
Wall Street Journal, February 28, 2014
City Mayor Bill de Blasio on Thursday reversed plans to allow three charter schools to open in city buildings, though he said he would allow more than a dozen other charter schools to open in Department of Education space, in the most significant education policy decision to date from the new administration.

Sorry state of schools means proposal to take over district must be explored
Opinion, Buffalo News, NY, February 28, 2014
Mayor Byron W. Brown has made his strongest statements to date about the possibility of taking over the city’s troubled school district. It’s about time.

NORTH CAROLINA

University City charter school Carolina STEM Academy to focus on hard sciences
Charlotte Observer, NC, February 28, 2014
In fall, University City will become home to the Charlotte region’s first charter school specializing in science, technology, engineering and math, intended exclusively for high school students.

What next for proponents of education choice?
Editorial, Burlington Times News, NC, February 28, 2014
A Wake County judge last week blocked private school tuition grants — what state lawmakers called “Opportunity Scholarships” when the General Assembly approved the program last year.

PENNSYLVANIA

Allentown School Board rejects two proposed charters
The Morning Call, PA, February 27, 2014
The Allentown School Board rejected two proposed charter schools Thursday, saying neither application had a strong enough curriculum to pass muster under charter school law.

At Easton hearing, Pennsylvania official hears calls for tougher charter school scrutiny
Lehigh Valley Express-News, PA, February 27, 2014
Pennsylvania Auditor General Eugene DePasquale is done waiting for Harrisburg to tackle charter school reform.

School officials discuss charter problems with auditor general
The Morning Call, PA, February 27, 2014
By the letter and spirit of the law, Pennsylvania charter schools are intended to work in collaboration with school districts, experimenting with new ideas and sharing innovative concepts that are proven to produce positive results.

TENNESSEE

For-profit charters remain a nonstarter
Editorial, The Tennessean, TN, February 28, 2014
It’s very disheartening to see the way so much of the legislation that is introduced in the General Assembly this year shows little thought for the implications of the bill’s actions. This is especially egregious when it is legislation affecting the education of Tennessee’s children.

Nashville schools scrap pay tied to teacher evaluations
WBIR, TN, February 27, 2014
Perhaps sensing a backlash from teachers, Metro Nashville Public Schools has abruptly scrapped a preliminary pay plan that would have tied their salaries to scores on state-mandated evaluations.

UTAH

Bill gives enrollment preference to grandchildren of charter school founders
Deseret News, UT, February 27, 2014
Both chambers of the Utah Legislature have passed a bill that allows the grandchildren of a charter school’s founder to enroll in that school without participating in an enrollment lottery.

Lawmakers reject bill granting tax credit to home-school parents
Deseret News, UT, February 27, 2014
Lawmakers Thursday narrowly rejected a proposal to grant $500 in tax credits to parents who home-school their children.

VIRGINIA

Educators share ideas for expanding magnet schools
Richmond Times-Dispatch, VA, February 27, 2014
The theory of expanded and possibly even regional magnet schools sounded great, and the research to back it up looked even better.

WISCONSIN

New London changes charter school designation
Appleton Post Crescent, WI, February 27, 2014
The School of Enterprise Marketing will no longer be a charter school at New London High School, but rather a project-based learning program available to all students.

We need voucher-school accountability now
Appleton Post Crescent, WI, February 27, 2014
Wisconsin residents were promised, when the 2013-15 budget was passed in June, that voucher schools would be held to the same accountability standards as public schools.

WYOMING

Anti-Common Core bill is misguided
Editorial, Wyoming News, WY, February 27, 2014
The issue: A House committee last week approved House Bill 97. It would toss away the Common Core Standards.

ONLINE LEARNING

Brandon School District offers online classes at high school
Macomb Daily, MI, February 27, 2014
When the Brandon School District opened a virtual school this year, the decision was made to dedicate a computer lab where students could take online classes during the regular school day.

Greenfield school board to talk virtual school, superintendent transition
Greenfield Record, MA, February 28, 2014
The Greenfield School Committee has called a special meeting tonight to consider what administrative services to sell to the town’s independent cyber school and to discuss plans for its superintendent transition. The Greenfield School Committee has called a special meeting tonight to consider what administrative services to sell to the town’s independent cyber school and to discuss plans for its superintendent transition.

Jeffco Virtual Academy offering online school to K-6 for 2014-15
Denver Post, CO, February 27, 2014
Jefferson County Public Schools’ 21st Century Virtual Academy is offering its online learning courses for kindergarten through sixth grade for the first time beginning in the 2014-15 school year.

Mixed marks for Farmington’s flexible learning days
Farmington Independent, MN, February 27, 2014
Farmington’s first digital learning day wasn’t without its bumps and false starts. But the stay-at-home make-up day on President’s Day went well enough that snow days filled with game shows and video games are likely a thing of the past in the district.

State-run virtual school better choice for Maine
Editorial, Portland Press Herald, ME, February 28, 2014
Putting for-profit academies on hold allows time to design a system that puts students first.

Virtual school classes could give students more options
Aiken Standard, SC, February 27, 2014
Virtual school programs have been around for many years in various forms – but nothing quite like the initiative proposed by Aiken County School District administrators.

Who Sends Their Kids to Charter Schools?

Christen McCurdy, Pacific Standard

“It’s actually a little bit difficult to talk about because I’m very resentful,” says Mari Mejor, who met with me at a Portland coffee shop to talk about her experiences at Trillium Charter School, which she attended the first two years after it opened.

I’m talking to Mejor—who I’ve known through mutual friends for several years—because I’m curious about the charter-school movement. Charter schools, which receive public funding but are privately administered, have grown rapidly over the past decade, both in terms of enrollment (1.8 million elementary and secondary students attended a charter school in the 2010-11 year, up from 340,000 in 1999-00) and the number of schools. Five percent of U.S. schools were charters in 2010-11, up from just two percent in 1999.

The first state charter law was passed in Minnesota in 1991, and in the two decades since, a majority of U.S. states have followed suit, with just eight that haven’t passed any sort of legislation. Many charter schools started from scratch, in abandoned retail spaces or modular buildings; some are traditional schools that decided to go the charter route; some have a religious affiliation.

The charter movement is often criticized as a step toward privatization of the public school system, and pro-charter lobbying groups are much more likely to contribute to Republican candidates than Democrats. But on the ground, the movement is more difficult to categorize politically.

A charter school is slightly more likely to be managed by a non-profit organization than a for-profit charter management organization; in fact, the idea of charters was conceived by progressive educator Ray Budde, who in 1974 suggested creating charter schools within larger schools as a space where teachers could experiment with new curricula and teaching methods, with the idea that when experiments were successful, they could be replicated elsewhere.

Still, I was curious about the face of the movement: who starts charter schools and who sends their children to them? So I put out a call on social media and contacted charter schools in Portland, where I live, paying visits to the two schools that responded positively to my request.

AS A CHILD, MEJOR says, she was an excellent student, first at private schools in Mexico, then at a traditional grade school in Portland, then at a Portland magnet school.

When Trillium opened, it was touted as a non-traditional, progressive learning environment, and Mejor’s mother thought it would be good for her. But in hindsight, she says, the school’s program was too unstructured for a middle schooler whose interest in academia was flagging: “I took a photography class where would literally skip and go to a cafe for a couple of hours.”

Mejor ended up transferring back to her magnet school and then dropping out for several years. Now in her 20s, she’s studying mathematics at Portland Community College and Portland State University, and while she has issues with the way math and science are taught in traditional schools, one thing that really bothers her in hindsight is that at Trillium, she wasn’t required to take a single mathematics class—though she did take about a semester of geometry. What sparked her interest in going back to school, she says, was moving to New Haven, Connecticut, and sitting in on classes at Yale, which were rigorous, but also fun.

“I felt like I’d been colorblind before, and all of a sudden I could see all these things that I couldn’t,” Mejor says. What’s more, she says, Yale students and graduates weren’t any smarter than the smart people she’d met in other walks of life; they just had a more fundamental and obvious belief in what they could accomplish. She also says that as a teenager, she had a really disdainful attitude toward math, science, and engineering. These were disciplines for boring, uncreative people, she says. Interesting people gravitated toward the arts.

As it happened, Trillium was one of two Portland-area schools that responded positively to my request for a visit. The school is situated in a former heavy equipment rental center on a major thoroughfare in a rapidly-gentrifying section of North Portland, and has about 300 students in its K-12 program.

As I waited for Kieran Connolly, Trillium’s executive director, to meet with me, I grabbed a copy of the school newspaper, which included a front-page article about the school’s only sports team, an ultimate Frisbee team called the Fighting Flowers. The team is in danger of disbanding due to lack of organization, according to the article, which even suggested students’ and faculty’s lack of experience with extracurricular sports was part of the problem. Tickled as I was by the Fighting Flowers as a mascot, I was also impressed that a school-sponsored publication allowed writers to point out problems and even criticize the school’s prevailing culture. Writers for my own high school newspaper could only do this in the most guarded and circuitous way possible.

“I didn’t grow up wanting to be a teacher, or a principal,” Connolly says, recounting that he started teaching in outdoor schools and later in alternative schools—and was drawn in by the concept of “democratic education,” which connotes voting, but is really about working in collaboration with students. “Any time I could collaborate with my students, things went so much better.”

Connolly says his interest in working at Trillium was less about working for a charter school than it was in working for Trillium in particular. He doesn’t mince words when talking about the charter movement as a whole. “They were supposed to be experimental,” he says. “The people who founded the charter school movement allowed it to be co-opted.”

If charters have not universally become, as critics like Diane Ravitch have warned, a gateway toward privatization, they’ve definitely become a flash point for critics of teachers’ unions. (Charter schools are non-union and their faculty often make less than teachers at traditional schools.) The documentary Waiting for Superman, whose director, Davis Guggenheim, earned progressive bonafides after the release of An Inconvenient Truth, lionizes the CEO of the Harlem Children’s Zone charter, while never pointing out that it’s vastly better funded than neighboring schools—and blaming the failure of the public school system on teachers’ unions’ willingness to protect “bad teachers,” while using a circular definition of bad teacher.”

No teacher at Trillium wants to de-fund public education, Connolly tells me, also pointing out that teachers and faculty make less than their peers in the Portland school district, and the school is less well-funded than other Portland Public Schools, which get a 20-percent cut of Trillium’s allocation from Oregon’s Department of Education.

Connolly also speaks candidly about the fact that Trillium is largely white, while being located in a historically black, if rapidly gentrifying neighborhood in Portland. “I think there’s a responsibility to address internal racism and work with the district on that,” he says, adding that he sees his responsibility as an educator as twofold: it’s partly to educate the kids and partly to help influence the national conversation about what works and what doesn’t in schools.

Connolly takes me on a tour of the school, which includes donated computers, a rooftop vegetable garden provided by a grant from a local civic organization, and a small blacktop playground. We end up in the high school journalism class, where I’m introduced as a reporter studying charter schools, and where I’ve been asked to answer a few questions about myself and my career.

Students ask about my work habits and whether I write on my own, or for fun. One tells me she’s never been to any other school and asks what they’re like. “It kind of depends on where you live,” I say, adding that there are differences between big schools in wealthy suburbs and small, rural districts and inner-city schools. I tell them that my high school was “small, but not as small as Trillium,” and very conservative by comparison. The students are then left to work on their stories for the next paper, which are due that week. Connolly sits at a table and chats with students about their stories, offering to read them as they go.

A student named Ivy walks up to where I’m sitting and offers more detail on her experience at Trillium. She attended kindergarten at a different school and hated it, she says. She thought it was just that she didn’t like the kids and that the problem was just that all kids are mean, but now she realizes the administration didn’t do enough to prevent bullying at school. Now a senior, Ivy’s the only student who’s been at Trillium for the entire 12 years it’s existed, and she says the small size “makes rivalries difficult, but also dating. Everybody’s friends and everybody’s single.”

Ivy says she’s thinking about going to art school after she graduates—“as you can probably guess,” she adds, waving her hand to indicate her wedge cut, day-glo orange earrings, and flannel shirt—but is worried about the “lifetime of crippling debt” that would probably entail.

Ivy and the other teenagers at Trillium strike me as self-aware, creative, and funny—the kind of kids I would have wanted as friends when I was their age and half-heartedly chanting along at mandatory pep assemblies.

Mejor told me she’s sure the school has improved over the years. From the numbers, it’s hard to tell one way or another. Trillium’s on-time graduation rate hovers at or below that of Portland Public Schools, with the district’s numbers being pretty dismal. About two out of three Portland Public School students can be expected to graduate on time. At Trillium in 2012, eight kids dropped out, and two stayed on for a fifth year—and the numbers for other Portland-area charter high schools are worse.

The most comprehensive study comparing students’ performance at charter schools to their performance at traditional public schools found that charter students do as well or slightly better than students at traditional schools, with black and Latino students in poverty showing the most improvement. Minority students, and kids living in poverty, are dramatically overrepresented in some charter schools, though some strive to represent the districts they’re in.

THE SECOND SCHOOL I visited, a grade school named Arthur Academy, is a cluster of out buildings in East Portland but is also part of a chain of six schools in the area. It opened in 2002 with a focus on “direct instruction”—where, essentially, 10 percent of what students do every day is new and 90 percent is review. It works particularly well for students with average or lower-than-average test scores who want to catch up, says Stephani Walker, the director of academics and leadership for the school.

Jill Domine, the director of operations, finance, and human relations at Arthur, says the school was started with money from the Walton Foundation (the charitable arm of Walmart), as well as incentive cash from the state of Oregon—but those funds have since dried up. “We rock,” Domine says, in terms of test scores and academic performance, “but we still run into issues of being accepted by the district. We have less funding and access to facilities.”

Domine says part of the reason the school isn’t well accepted is that it’s non-union, but there’s also a perception that they funnel money away from Portland Public Schools, when in fact they’ve brought some kids—and their funding—in from other districts. “I would, as a district, be appreciative of the extra students and extra money on their pocket,” she says.

“A lot of the charter schooling and home schooling is people who don’t want their kids exposed to things like evolution, or is based on racist or exclusionary principles,” says Markus Roberts, whose three children attend Forest Grove Community School, which opened in 2007 in a former funeral home in Forest Grove, a farm-town-turned-exurb 25 miles west of Portland.

Roberts attended early planning meetings for the school, and he says that early on, organizers were less interested in “pandering to parents’ fears” than in getting parents involved and enthusiastic. One parent, he says, said, “I want my kids taught the things I don’t want them to know” in a meeting—and the school’s culture makes it open to discussing dangerous chemicals in a chemistry class, or addressing alternative lifestyles and social justice issues.

Roberts and his family lived in Costa Rica when his oldest child attended a Montessori school—“a very open, international school, a very enriching environment.” Then they moved back to the United States, first living in Arizona (where the public school his son attended was “not an enriching environment”) and then moving to Oregon and making contact with staff at the newly-formed charter school.

Roberts helped start a math club for students, and later a gizmotics club, the thrust of which is to give students hands-on experiences with the kinds of problems engineers face by asking them to build devices with arbitrary requirements. The school actively encourages parental involvement, with other parents leading acting and improv groups, and one helping start a garden on school grounds. Roberts was tagged to lead the math club after, he says, he “grumbled” about the way mathematics is taught during a planning meeting.

“Some organizations you contact them it’s very clear what the hierarchy is. In a military organization, it’s the rank on their shoulder. In a company, you can tell managers by their name tags,” Roberts says. “At this school it was hard to tell the teachers from the administrators from the parents from the teachers.”

ALMOST EVERYONE I TALKED to for this story lived in Oregon, where 3.7 percent of students are enrolled in charter schools, compared to 5.9 percent in California, 12 percent in Arizona, and a whopping 37.8 percent in the District of Columbia. The Center for Education Reform gave the state a C for charter education support, and I suspect if I’d focused my reporting elsewhere, I would have walked into a completely different set of schools and groups of people. The charter concept is so broad that it can include grassroots schools, those built around certain educational philosophies, for-profit chain schools, and religiously based centers.

Most of the people I spoke with seemed less interested in, or aligned with, the charter movement as a whole. In fact, almost all were ambivalent or skeptical about it, and the founder of a chain of California charters told me he thinks most of the political barriers to charter creation should be there. This just happens to be the tool kit parents, teachers, and communities have to do something slightly different from what other schools might be doing.

Roberts says he’d like to see more “secular, left-wing” minded people in the charter school movement. In most cases, it seems, conservatives have dominated the conversation, he says. “When people say, ‘Think of the children,’ almost always what they’re talking about is put your hands over that kids’ eyes so that they don’t see something horrible,” Roberts says. “They almost always mean, let’s protect this kid from something that causes them to have thoughts.”

Education Can Be For Students and For-Profit

Teacher Union “Cashing in on Kids” campaign launched on false assumptions 

CER Press Release
Washington, DC
February 27, 2014

Kara Kerwin, president of The Center for Education Reform, issued the following response to the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) and In the Public Interest latest attack on charter schools:

“Performance-based accountability is the hallmark of charter schools and reforms aimed at improving student learning. It’s quite galling for the American Federation of Teachers and In the Public Interest to trumpet accountability and transparency in the charter sector when it is those same players that fight so hard and spend millions of taxpayer dollars on politics to maintain the status quo in education.

“Unlike all other public schools, charters must be proactive in their efforts to stay open. They must set and meet rigorous academic goals, and actually meet or exceed their state’s proficiency standards. Unlike the conventional public schools that intentionally remain under the radar, charter schools operate under intense scrutiny from teachers unions, the media, and lawmakers. In states with strong charter school laws that allow for objective oversight, it is clear that performance-based accountability is working.

“In a rhetorical gymnastics routine we’ve come to expect from teacher unions, this latest campaign against education reform irresponsibly suggests that profit and student success are mutually exclusive, ignoring the fact that K-12 education in the U.S. is a $607 billion enterprise annually.

“There are over a dozen high-quality management firms that are driven by capital operating in the public charter school sector. They are building public-private partnerships whose bottom line is for the greater good of the public interest. Their entire business model is predicated on student outcomes. If it’s not, they will lose business.

“By law, for-profit companies may only contract with the non-profit governing board of a charter school. These are public schools that are held to the same state standards, open meeting laws, and transparency. Open-enrollment policies must apply, and students that attend charter schools, regardless of the tax status of the organization that manages it, do so by choice.

“Education management companies bring investment and capital to the communities they serve, creating jobs, innovation, and cost-saving strategies. Most assume great financial risk on behalf of their non-profit clients to build infrastructure and facilities in communities that in any other industry would most likely not be considered ideal or open to business. In fact, like most charter schools, even those in public-private partnerships, receive on average 30% less per pupil than their traditional school peers whose management has no accountability or incentive to improve student outcomes.

“This latest attempt by the AFT to discredit charter schools is nothing more than an effort to stifle the calls for greater accountability in our conventional public schools that the American public demands.”

Daily Headlines for February 27, 2014

Click here for Newswire, the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else – spiced with a dash of irreverence – from the nation’s leading voice in school reform. 

NATIONAL COVERAGE

Federal takeover of school curriculum
Column, Manteca Bulletin, CA, February 27, 2014
Ever since Congress began pouring federal tax dollars into public schools, parents have been solicitous to have Congress write into law a prohibition against the federal government writing curriculum or lesson plans, or imposing a uniform national curriculum. Parents want those decisions made at the local level by local school boards, which are, or should be, subject to the watchful eyes of local citizens and parents.

STATE COVERAGE

ALABAMA

AL teacher pay raise replaced by 1-time bonus
WSFA, AL, February 26, 2014
A $5.9 million spending plan passed out of a Senate Committee Wednesday slashing the governor’s proposed 2 percent pay raise for teachers.

ALASKA

Charter Schools hit road bump in Alaska House
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner, AK, February 27, 2014
Gov. Sean Parnell’s omnibus education bill was questioned Wednesday by members of a House committee who focused on a provision to provide transportation for students in charter schools.

CALIFORNIA

Teacher tenure is still needed to attract the best: Letter
Opinion, Los Angeles Daily News, CA, February 26, 2014
Re “Teacher tenure comes at expense of children’s education” (Richard Riordan and Tim Rutten, Feb. 21): Republicans like Richard Riordan would love to get rid of unions, and have a long history of voting against workers’ bargaining rights, minimum wage, equal salaries for women, health care, unemployment benefits, etc.

COLORADO

DeGrow: School boards push teacher accountability
Opinion, Greeley Tribune, CO, February 27, 2014
Union leaders are actively challenging school principals’ newfound authority to keep the worst teachers out of their classrooms. The state legislative majority has shrunk from the chance to reward the best teachers. But some local school boards have begun to take the reins of reform.

CONNECTICUT

Education Reform Hurts Local Students
Letter, Hartford Courant, CT, February 26, 2014
The rhetoric of politicians involved in the corporate education reform movement includes statements such as, “Strong schools are the surest path to our nation’s long-term economic success,” which was voiced by Delaware Gov. Jack Markell as the National Governors Association unveiled the Common Core standards in June 2010.

DELAWARE

State may ax private school transportation stipend
News Journal, DE, February 26, 2014
Private school parents are protesting a proposal to eliminate a stipend they get to help pay for transporting their kids to school, saying they pay taxes and deserve at least something from the state’s education budget.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

D.C. International charter school may lose $6 million in expected city funds
Washington Post, DC, February 26, 2014
The D.C. Council set aside $6 million last spring to help D.C International — a new language immersion charter school for students in grades six through 12 — renovate its home-to-be, a building on the site of the old Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Northwest Washington.

FLORIDA

Accountability exists with private vouchers
Letter, Sun-Sentinel, FL, February 27, 2014
The Feb. 24 editorial, “Make testing a part of school vouchers,” starts out, “It’s an educational fix long overdue.” I have no words to express the depth of my gratitude as a parent of a child who is taking advantage of the school voucher program: Step Up For Students.

Florida School Evaluations: Get Grades Right
Editorial, The Ledger, FL, February 27, 2014
State Education Commissioner Pam Stewart presented her newly revamped school grading system Feb. 18 to the State Board of Education in Orlando.

GEORGIA

Fayette BoE: Charter school given until May 1 to make its case
The Citizen, GA, February 26, 2014
The Fayette County Board of Education on Monday amended its charter school acceptance policy, but exempted a current petitioner from retroactive deadlines. The vote on the amendment was followed by another unanimous vote to set a May 1 deadline for Liberty Tech Charter School to submit its petition for a charter school in Fayette County.

New charter school partnership lets students earn associates degrees
WALB-TV, GA, February 27, 2014
A charter school and technical college are working together to get more students to continue their education.

Several Atlanta principals to be removed from their schools
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, GA, February 26, 2014
Principals at about seven Atlanta schools are being removed before next school year, said city school board Chairman Courtney English on Wednesday.

ILLINOIS

Do charters expel too many students?
Editorial, Chicago Tribune, IL, February 27, 2014
We’ve long heard complaints from Chicago Public Schools teachers that their counterparts in charter schools are too quick to expel students.

Why do charter schools expel more students?
Editorial, Chicago Sun-Times, IL, February 27, 2014
One pernicious, long-held suspicion about Chicago public charter schools turns out to be true.

LOUISIANA

Injunctions lifted that prevented Tangipahoa school voucher program
The Advocate, LA, February 26, 2014
A federal appeals court has vacated a virtually toothless injunction granted by a federal judge in 2012 that blocked Louisiana’s school voucher program in Tangipahoa Parish.

MISSOURI

The debate on Common Core rages even as teachers are moving ahead
St. Louis Post-Dispatch, MO, February 27, 2014
Affton High School teacher Cathy Cartier wondered if any of the Missouri legislators who are debating bills that would abolish new learning goals had ever seen them in action.

NEW JERSEY


A winning NJ charter school awaits word on its fate
Editorial, Star Ledger, NJ, February 27, 2014
A charter school in Hoboken, “Hola,” is doing a terrific job educating kids with an innovate dual-language program, and parents are lining up to compete for scarce seats.

Gov. Christie’s new crisis: Protests grow over state control of Newark schools
Washington Post Blog, DC, February 27, 2014
Public protests in Newark are growing over an effort by Superintendent Cami Anderson, who was appointed to run the state-operated district by Gov. Chris Christie, to reshape the city’s school system.

Pequannock BOE president: State stabbed us in back with School Choice Program
The Record, NJ, February 27, 2014
After nearly 12 months of back-and-forth with the New Jersey Department of Education (DOE), the school district has learned that it will not receive a reimbursement for the hundreds of thousands of dollars it lost last year in aid as a result of its participation in the state’s School Choice Program.

NEW MEXICO

RR educators starting charter school in ABQ
Rio Racho Observer, NM, February 27, 2014
“We need to start our own school,” Rio Rancho High School teacher Justin Baiardo decided a couple of years ago, and that school, Explore Academy, is expected to open for the 2014-15 school year in Albuquerque.

NEW YORK

Charter School Supporters to Rally in Albany Tuesday
NY1, NY, February 27, 2014
Supporters of charter schools are taking their fight to the state capital. On Tuesday, a group of school leaders say they will shut down their schools so students and parents can join them in Albany.

Education tax credit would help all schools
Opinion, Olean Times Herald, NY, February 26, 2014
There’s a simple plan to increase investment in education in New York state without raising taxes. It’s called the Education Investment Tax Credit.

Eva Moskowitz: I’ll sue de Blasio for charter-school space
New York Post, NY, February 27, 2014
New York’s largest charter-schools operator is threatening to sue Mayor de Blasio if the city boots its students out of space promised in the fall.

NORTH CAROLINA

Durham children in running for state vouchers
Herald Sun, NC, February 26, 2014
Nearly 200 local children were among the 4,700 from across the state who applied for Opportunity Scholarships.

Good questions from both sides on private school vouchers
Opinion, Charlotte Observer, NC, February 26, 2014
For starters, why do we need vouchers? North Carolina’s Constitution mandates a sound basic education is to be made available to every child in our state at no cost. So why would a parent choose to pay for something already provided for free? The obvious answer is the parent doesn’t believe the free education being provided is best for their child. Why not?

PENNSYLVANIA

Attempt to sell Burgwin School in Hazelwood fails again
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, February 26, 2014
A second attempt to sell the closed Burgwin School in Hazelwood to the Hazelwood Initiative for use as a Propel charter school failed tonight.

District names four finalists in sale of six closed properties
Philadelphia Daily News, PA
February 27, 2014
FOUR FINALISTS have emerged in the potential sale of six recently closed school properties, district officials announced yesterday.

PIAA head: Charter sports may be illegal
Lewistown Sentinel, PA, February 27, 2014
The peace and calm that has marked the brief tenure of Dr. Robert Lombardi as executive director of the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association might be coming to an end.

Pocono Mountain Charter School battle goes on
Pocono Record, PA, February 27, 2014
The Pocono Mountain Charter School has survived its latest legal test, but the marathon battle with the Pocono Mountain School District is far from over.

Why don’t teachers have role in Action Plan 2.0?
Opinion, Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, February 27, 2014
THE NEW Action Plan 2.0, presented by Superintendent William Hite at last week’s School Reform Commission meeting, contains some worthy goals. As the Daily News points out in its Feb. 18 editorial, no one can argue with the goal of having a great school for each and every child in Philadelphia to attend. The teachers and professional school staff in Philadelphia work to make this a reality every day.

SOUTH CAROLINA

Parents should first research charter schools
Editorial, Hilton Head Island Packet, SC, February 26, 2014
Charter schools are increasingly popular. But it takes parental homework to decide if one is a good fit for a student.

VIRGINIA

City groups oppose takeover of school system
Richmond Times-Dispatch, VA, February 27, 2014
Two groups representing parents and students in Petersburg made a clear, strong statement Wednesday in opposition to the idea of Chesterfield County taking over the city’s school system.

WASHINGTON

Democrats bet wrong in gamble on school funding
Column, The Olympian, WA, February 27, 2014
Of all the election-year gambles the state Senate might have taken this session, we didn’t expect a game of chicken with the U.S. Department of Education.

WEST VIRGINIA

Senate OKs teacher pay raise ‘on borrowed money’
Charleston Gazette, WV, February 26, 2014
Legislators are using more than $34 million in borrowed money to provide a pay raise for public school teachers and service personnel, Sen. Brooks McCabe, D-Kanawha, warned Wednesday.

ONLINE LEARNING

Find a fairer way to fix ‘cyber double dip’ in Pa.
Letter, Lehigh Valley Express-Times, PA, February 27, 2014
House Bill 618, summarized in the Feb. 15 column by Pennsylvania state Reps. Joe Emrick and Mike Reese, is a thoughtful and comprehensive piece of charter reform legislation. A majority of the elements in the bill are concepts we have supported for years and continue to do so. But the proposed treatment of cyber-school pension expenses runs counter to the logic, balance and fairness evident in the rest of the bill.

Give students more options, approve Maine Virtual Academy
Opinion, Bangor Daily News, ME, February 267, 2014
Creating a variety of learning options for all of Maine’s students is critically important to their success. I know this from firsthand experience, having recently retired as a Maine school superintendent with 17 years running school districts across Maine.

GEVS considering new virtual learning program
Hillsboro Times Gazette, OH, February 26, 2014
McClain staffers on Tuesday evening presented information to the Greenfield Exempted Village Schools Board of Education on a new virtual learning program that, while more expensive than the current program, would offer much more opportunity for all students.

John Carroll institutes ‘cyber days’ in place of snow days
Baltimore Sun, MD, February 27, 2014
The John Carroll School campus might be closed for snow days, but that doesn’t mean students aren’t in class, albeit safe at home in their pajamas and with their laptops.

Make snow days into virtual school days
Letter, The Record, NJ, February 27, 2014
We’ve read accounts about how during a recent snow day, students in the Pascack Valley Regional High School District still had their lessons by using school-issued laptops to log on to their teachers’ websites at precisely 8 a.m. to connect with the day’s activities and assignments. The teachers checked if their students participated in the online lessons and marked them “present” or “absent” accordingly.

Money questions remain with $200M school tech upgrade
Salt Lake Tribune, UT, February 26, 2014
A massive push to expand technology in Utah schools cleared its first serious hurdle Wednesday — despite persistent and unanswered questions about how sponsors plan to pay for the $200 million price tag.

Schooling in Cyberspace
Lodi News-Sentinel, CA, February 27, 2014
Loretta Hans was seeking a flexible education program that would allow her first-grader to learn at her own pace and from the comfort and safety of her own home.

Senate committee won’t vote on virtual charter sports bill
Statehouse File, IN, February 27, 2014
The Senate Education Committee won’t move legislation to let virtual charter school students participate in sports at traditional public schools, the chairman said Wednesday.

Teachers Believe Rewards Outweigh Challenges

A new survey commissioned by Scholastic in conjunction with The Gates Foundation shows that 88 percent of teachers believe the rewards of teaching outweigh the challenges.

This statistic was compounded by the 89 percent of teachers who reported satisfaction with their jobs, which went unchanged from 2011. An overwhelming 98 percent also viewed teaching in the greater context of making a positive change, rather than viewing it as just another way to make a living.

Although there is widespread job satisfaction, teaching does not come without its obstacles. 38 percent reported they would like to see increased parental interaction and involvement in their child’s education, a testament to the long-acknowledged integral role that parents play in education.

Further, three in four teachers feel their voice is not adequately heard at the school, state or federal levels of education.

The survey was conducted in July 2013, using a sample of over 20,157 PreK-12 public school teachers.

Daily Headlines for February 26, 2014

Click here for Newswire, the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else – spiced with a dash of irreverence – from the nation’s leading voice in school reform. 

NATIONAL COVERAGE

School reform should pay heed to employers’ needs
Opinion, Washington Times, DC, February 25, 2014
As the discussion of inequality intensifies, it has further highlighted the importance of school reform and school choice in terms of charter schools and school vouchers.

States: Stop blaming Washington for Common Core
Opinion, Daily Caller, DC, February 25, 2014
Still, Common Core wasn’t somehow foisted on unwilling states. Now that the federalized standards and assessments regime has become unpopular in many parts of the country, state elected officials often speak of Common Core as if it had been imposed from above. But that’s not the case. States happily implemented Common Core — and they did it for money.

STATE COVERAGE

CALIFORNIA

Antioch’s Dozier Libbey teachers file petition to form charter school
Contra Coasta Times, CA, February 25, 2014
Teachers at Dozier Libbey Medical High School filed a petition this week with the Antioch Unified School District to convert the health care-themed public school to a charter.

County challenges charter school admissions process
Los Altos Town Crier, CA, February 26, 2014
The Santa Clara County Office of Education sent a letter to Bullis Charter School last week ordering administrators to correct their enrollment practices to conform to state law.

LAUSD reports increase in charter school co-location approvals
LA School Report, CA, February 25, 2014
LA Unified has released a preliminary list of charter school co-location proposals, showing that the district is offering more traditional school sites for co-locations for 2014-15 than in either of the previous two school years.

COLORADO

Teacher’s Union to oppose new ‘reform’ and funding school bill
North Denver News, CO, February 25, 2014
Michael Johnston’s newest reform bill has already drawn the opposition of Colorado teachers, and could cause a major rift between Democrats and their strongest supporters in an election year.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

The most meaningless teacher evaluation exercise ever?
Washington Post Blog, DC, February 26, 2014
If ever there were a meaningless exercise in the annals of evaluation, it would be this one. The Florida Times-Union newspaper sued the state Education Department to get access to what are called “value-added” scores of teachers that are used to make high-stakes decisions about their jobs.

FLORIDA

Appeals group: State should back MacDill charter rejection
The Tampa Tribune, FL, February 25, 2014
The group that makes recommendations to top state education officials on charter school appeals is siding with the Hillsborough County School Board in its decision to turn down an application for a charter school on MacDill Air Force Base.

Superintendent Browning says beware of teacher eval data
The Tampa Tribune, FL, February 26, 2014
Pasco County school district officials and the teachers union say it’s a move that could sow confusion rather than shed light on how well teachers are doing their jobs.

Testing times
Editorial, Tallahassee Democrat, FL, February 26, 2014
Think back to a schoolteacher who had a positive impact on your life. Chances are, your choice wasn’t based on explanations of quadratic equations or whether she helped advance your reading skills a full grade level.

GEORGIA

Georgia politicians rip national education standards
Cherokee Tribune, GA, February 26, 2014
Republican lawmakers indulged their conservative wing Tuesday by opposing national education standards, though the watered-down legislation does nothing to change the standards at the heart of the controversy.

IDAHO

Charter school nears enrollment goal
Idaho Mountain Express and Guide, ID, February 26, 2014
With the start of the 2014-2015 school year still six months away, Syringa Mountain School, Blaine County’s new state-funded charter school, is approaching its goal of 165 students.

ILLINOIS

Charter schools’ expulsion rate vastly higher than rest of CPS
Chicago Tribune, IL, February 26, 2014
As it continues to modify strict disciplinary policies in an effort to keep students in the classroom, Chicago Public Schools on Tuesday released data showing privately run charter schools expel students at a vastly higher rate than the rest of the district.

LOUISIANA

Changes to Louisiana teacher tenure law discussed by Jindal administration, education officials
Times-Picayune, LA, February 25, 2014
A controversial teacher tenure law passed in 2012 could be tweaked again this year, after administration officials and educational leaders discussed possible statutorial changes on Tuesday (Feb. 25).

MICHIGAN

School District, Union Working Together To Try To Ban Charter Schools
Michigan Capital Confidential, MI, February 26, 2014
Charter public schools in Michigan have been blamed by many in the media and by advocates for more school spending as part of the reason conventional public schools have problems.

MINNESOTA

How one high school is tackling the achievement gap
Star Tribune, MN, February 25, 2014
It’s big bragging rights for the state’s biggest school district. While the Twin Cities’ other large districts struggled to lessen the disparity between white and minority students’ proficiency in reading, math and other core subjects, Anoka-Hennepin surpassed goals set by the state.

MISSISSIPPI

Parents, advocates push for special-needs vouchers
Jackson Clarion Ledger, MS, February 26, 2014
Supporters of a school voucher for special-needs children rallied Tuesday at the state Capitol, where two bills await legislative action.

NEBRASKA

Parents testifying in the Legislature say time for charter schools is now
Omaha World Herald, NE, February 25, 2014
A legislative hearing on a bill to create charter schools in Nebraska came down to time. Anxious parents said Tuesday that they couldn’t wait any longer for Nebraska public schools — namely the Omaha Public Schools — to get their act together.

NEVADA

Study Shows Racial Achievement Gaps In Reno Students
Capital Radio, NV, February 26, 2014
For the first time the Washoe County School District is releasing data that show significant achievement gaps by race. The district is beginning what it expects to be a difficult conversation.

Teacher evaluation specifics lacking as implementation nears
Las Vegas Review-Journal, NV, February 25, 2014
State lawmakers were updated Tuesday on the first statewide teacher evaluation system being implemented in the fall, but a lot of questions remain.

NEW JERSEY

Charter schools strip residents of their rights
Commentary, Cherry Hill Courier Post, NJ, February 26, 2014
After attending “community meetings” concerning the possibility of two more Renaissance school operators coming to Camden, it is obvious that preserving what constitutionally belongs to the people of Camden, democratic public schools, is quickly becoming a thing of the past. While some of the city’s elite seem fine with people’s rights being taken away, as public school educators, we deem what is going on here unacceptable.

Newark teachers, students protest district’s layoff plan
Star-Ledger, NJ, February 25, 2014
About 400 Newark teachers and their supporters voiced pronounced opposition last night to the school district’s proposal to base planned layoffs of more than 1,000 teachers on classroom effectiveness rather than seniority.

NEW YORK

The cynical Cuomo-Tisch Common Core tug-of-war
Opinion, New York Daily News, NY, February 26, 2014
This month, the New York State Board of Regents released a “Path Forward” for implementation of Common Core standards. Though the report posed as a course correction, it is little more than a Trojan Horse.

NORTH CAROLINA

NAACP equates vouchers to school segregation effort
WRAL, NC, February 25, 2014
North Carolina’s school voucher program is the state’s latest assault on minorities, civil rights advocates said Tuesday.

Public, charter school collaboration in the future?
Durham Herald Sun, NC, February 25, 2014
Duke University economics professor Helen Ladd believes that charter schools have a place on the outskirts – not at the center – of public education.

PENNSYLVANIA

Duquesne charter school denied
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, PA, February 26, 2014
Duquesne City School District’s court-appointed receiver Paul B. Long has denied the application for a proposed charter school.

Letting colleges and universities authorize charter schools doesn’t necessarily mean better results: Op-Ed
Patriot News, PA, February 25, 2014
In what has become an almost annual occurrence, Pennsylvania lawmakers are discussing changes to the state’s Charter School Law.

Speakers question charter school funding
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, February 26, 2014
State Auditor General Eugene DePasquale doesn’t think the Legislature is moving fast enough to revise Pennsylvania’s charter school law to address funding and other issues.

Vulnerable students need high-quality teachers
Opinion, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, February 26, 2014
Black leaders and educational researchers have long advocated for better learning conditions for black children, and decades of research have shown that black parents care deeply about their children’s education but are often marginalized by educational inequities.

TENNESSEE

Ailing Nashville schools spark takeover interest from 2 charter groups
The Tennessean, TN, February 26, 2014
Might the same Metro school board that has clashed at times with charter schools hand the keys of a struggling district school to one?

For-profit charter schools would be bad business for Tennessee
Column, The Tennessean, TN, February 26, 2014
The over simplified argument that those two tasks are similar is one of the arguments charter school lobbyists are using to try to convince the state legislature that charter schools should be allowed to be profit-making businesses, not nonprofits run by boards as they are now.

VIRGINIA

Norfolk drops plan for charter schools
WAVY, VA, February 25, 2014
Norfolk Public Schools has dropped plans to turn some low-performing schools into charter schools. 10 On Your Side first told you about this plan in an in-depth report in October. It would have allowed the Superintendent to turn ten low-performing schools into public conversion charters.

WASHINGTON

Inslee plans bill requiring state test scores in teacher evaluations
Seattle Times, WA, February 25, 2014
Gov. Jay Inslee met Tuesday afternoon with lawmakers from both parties to hammer out a compromise that would allow the state to keep its waiver from the federal No Child Left Behind law — and keep control over some $40 million that comes with the waiver.

WEST VIRGINIA

Vote on teacher pay raise bill postponed
Martinsburg Journal, WV, February 26, 2014
The West Virginia Senate postponed voting Tuesday on a bill to provide salary increases for teachers and school service personnel.

WISCONSIN

Bills would help state’s rural schools
Opinion, La Crosse Tribune, WI, February 26, 21014
As people in our area know, schools are at the center of rural communities. First and foremost, schools provide an education for the next generation, but they also serve as a gathering place for community members and provide extracurricular activities opportunities for students.

ONLINE LEARNING

Aiken Co. School Changes Put More Students Online
WJBF, GA, February 25, 2014
Major changes are on the way for Aiken County schools. The district has been working on a five year strategic plan, which is expected to affect North Augusta High School, Levealle-McCampbell Middle School in Graniteville and Ridge Spring-Monetta Elementary, Middle and High Schools. But there was one program aimed at helping students take that walk across the stage at the end of each year.

Audit finds poor oversight Utah schools …. online education
Salt Lake Tribune, UT, February 26, 2014
Two private companies are being paid millions in Utah tax dollars to recruit online students who boost enrollment for mostly charter schools — on paper.

Elanco’s virtual learning program is gaining momentum
Lancaster New Era, PA, February 25, 2014
Boosting cyber-school enrollment to compete with charters and offer students a wider range of learning possibilities is part of the plan at the Eastern Lancaster County School District.

High school taken online a new option for some
KAIT8, AR, February 25, 2014
With the flexibility and convenience, online classes have become more popular among college students. But one local student chose the keyboard over the classroom early by enrolling in online classes her junior year of high school.

iPads are a big hit in Putnam City classrooms
The Oklahoman, OK, February 26, 2014
Putnam City School District voters in Oklahoma passed a $6 million technology bond in 2013 that already is benefiting students.

Liberty promotes digital learning with flipped classrooms, online independent study courses
Carroll County Times, MD, February 26, 2014
Taylor Jones is enjoying the new way she’s learning math.
Jones, a freshman, is part of a conceptual algebra class at Liberty High School that’s functioning under a flipped classroom model.

More Mass. Students To Learn Virtually
WBUR, MA, February 25, 2014
The Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education unanimously approved the state’s second online K-12 academy today, despite concerns that virtual schools lack oversight and accountability.

Pascack Valley Regional School District hopeful that virtual school day will count
The Record, NJ, February 25, 2014
For their first try at a virtual snow day, Pascack Valley Regional High School District officials agree it was a successful one.

Probing Question: Do cyber charter schools help or hurt the educational system?
Penn State News, PA, February 25, 2014
When charter schools were first created in the early 1990s, they were viewed as alternative learning environments for a small number of students. The ideal model was to unhitch these schools from many of the state laws and district regulations governing traditional public schools, and allow them to tailor the education to families looking for an option outside the conventional system.

Proposal for state-run virtual school wins preliminary approval
Portland Press Herald, ME, February 25, 2014
The House of Representatives on Tuesday gave preliminary approval to a bill to study the creation of a state-run virtual school and place a moratorium on private virtual charter schools.

NEWSWIRE: February 25, 2014

Vol. 16, No. 8

HONORING TEACHERS. A significant portion of commentary on education policy has always focused on the hard work and devotion that is demanded of teachers in our society. But what has unfortunately happened is the same forces that trumpet the hard work of teachers end up hurting them, with a broken status quo and a fed up American public who overwhelmingly want increased accountability in schools.  There’s no doubt teaching is an honorable profession, and right now too many states lack teacher quality provisions that both treat teachers with respect and dignity while also serving the interests of students. The dedication of teachers was recently quantified in a Gates Foundation/Scholastic survey, with 89 percent of teachers reporting job satisfaction, and 88 percent of teachers agreeing the rewards of teaching outweigh the challenges. Hiring and pay practices that incorporate performance in the classroom to ensure all students have access to quality teachers will give some of the most important professionals in America the credit they deserve.

TENNESSEE’S CHANCE TO EXPAND OPTIONS. State legislators have been presented with a great opportunity to expand educational options for families by attracting quality charter school operators to the Volunteer State. Proposals in Nashville are under consideration to allow public-private partnerships to proliferate in the state’s charter school sector, allowing for operators with proven track records of success to oversee quality schools. Tennessee’s current charter school law has a lot of room for improvement, chiefly because it does not allow for multiple, independent authorizers, which maximizes the creation of high-functioning charter schools. Permitting entry to reputable operators with a vested interest in the success of schools will be a step in the right direction in creating more and better choices for families.

TOOLS FOR SUCCESS. Recently, the district of York, PA felt compelled to close a charter school, citing a number of financial conflicts as well as concerns over meeting academic benchmarks. In a separate case, a York charter application was recently denied, contrary to the applicant’s claim of being thorough and reporting all necessary information to receive approval. In both instances, the charter school proponents cite tension between themselves and the district in their quest to provide a viable alternative to local students. These stories are unfortunately too common in states where there is a lack of strong, independent authorizers, leaving local districts with authority despite them not being the best entity to oversee charter schools. As a result, local control often leads to contentious relationships between charter operators — both current and aspiring — and district officials at the expense of the students they’re meant to be serving.

OPPORTUNITY SCHOLARSHIP SETBACK. In a disappointing decision, a North Carolina judge issued an injunction against the newly implemented Opportunity Scholarship program, which was set to begin in the 2014-15 school year. It’s one thing if the program was stopped in its tracks before ever getting off the ground, but over 4,000 low-income parents have already applied, thinking they were finally going to be able to choose a better education for their child, making this injunction all the more appalling. Obstacles such as this injunction, which is the result of separately filed lawsuits against the Opportunity Scholarship program, are an affront to the civil rights of families and the 74 percent of Americans who support school choice. The halting of scholarships in a state where only 30 percent of low-income children demonstrate proficiency on state tests makes it paramount that North Carolina families continue to fight for power and options in education.

DIGITAL EXPERIENCE GETS LOCAL INK. Last week, a small Arizona newspaper featured a human interest story on the positive online learning experience of digital student Abigail Austin. The story went into detail about Austin’s typical daily routine in a not-so-typical online learning environment, and how it best fits her learning needs. According to The Media and the Digital Learning Revolution, stories like Abigail’s crop up all over the country in papers that may not have a national readership, but have the interests of their neighbors at heart. Recognition by ‘digiformers’ and choice activists of the importance of appealing locally is half the battle in bringing innovative learning models to their communities.

Daily Headlines for February 25, 2014

Click here for Newswire, the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else – spiced with a dash of irreverence – from the nation’s leading voice in school reform. 

NATIONAL COVERAGE

A ‘Common Core’ firestorm
Pilot-Tribune, IA, February 25, 2014
The “Common Core” is the red-hot controversy in education today, with some states fighting to dump the standards and the National Education Association, which represents teachers, claiming the implementation of the standards has been “completely botched.”

Low Standards Upstream Cause Problems Downstream
Letter, Wall Street Journal, February 25, 2014
“Remedial Courses’ New Test” (U.S. News, Feb. 18) discusses a disheartening trend of weakening academic standards to raise graduation rates.

NC school vouchers on hold
Watchdog.org, February 25, 2014
About 4,000 North Carolina families must wait for the courts to untangle a legal challenge involving the state’s voucher program before they’ll know what schools their children can attend next year.

School Choice is the Only Choice for a Better Education
Column, Town Hall, February 25, 2014
The idea that parents have no control over where their children go to school is unthinkable. The public school education system currently in America is exactly that. Children must go to a school based not on choice, but on five numbers-their zip code.

STATE COVERAGE

ALABAMA

AEA blasts bill by Sen. Del Marsh limiting role of seniority in determining teacher layoffs
The Huntsville Times Blog, AL, February 25, 2014
The Alabama Education Association has blasted proposed legislation that would limit how much local school systems can consider seniority when deciding which teachers to lay off when they are forced to make cutbacks.

ALASKA

State should build on success of public charter schools
Column, Anchorage Daily News, AK, February 25, 2014
This is, officially, the Education Session in Juneau. You have our attention. Actually, you had our attention at the State of the State address. It was during this speech that Gov. Sean Parnell acknowledged public charter school success.

CALIFORNIA

Charters on New Prop. Z Rules: ‘Absolutely a Slap in the Face’
Voice of San Diego, CA, February 25, 2014
When the San Diego Unified school board voted to raise the bar on charter schools seeking Prop. Z funding, nobody talked about Old Town Academy.

FLORIDA

FCAT merit-based teacher pay: an unfair indicator
The Independent Florida Alligator, FL, February 25, 2014
Luckily, our FCAT days are behind us. After all, the snacks used as bribery tactics and all of the time out of class in the world couldn’t make up for the fact that state standardized testing is a waste of schools’ time and an unfair indicator of teacher and student success.

Florida Dept. of Education Releases Teachers’ Grades After Losing Lawsuit
The Ledger, FL, February 24, 2014
Polk County’s teachers performed slightly better than the state average in a controversial grading system the Florida Department of Education made public Monday after losing a lawsuit that forced its release.

Make testing a part of school vouchers
Editorial, Sun Sentinel, FL, February 24, 2014
It’s an educational fix long overdue. So give Florida Senate President Don Gaetz credit for insisting that private schools that receive state-supported vouchers administer the same accountability tests as their public-school counterparts.

Questions abound as state releases teacher evaluation scores
Tampa Bay Times, FL, February 25, 2014
Pasco County language arts teacher Valerie Smith learned early Monday that part of her 2013 job evaluation was being made public.

ILLINOIS

Parent groups push ISAT boycott in CPS
Chicago Tribune, IL, February 25, 2014
A coalition of Chicago Public Schools parent groups is calling for students to skip the Illinois Standards Achievement Test, which is being replaced this year by another test as a key element for promotions and eligibility for elite schools.

MARYLAND

Signs of trouble in county schools?
Editorial, Baltimore Sun, MD, February 24, 2014
Last week’s decision by Baltimore County’s PTA Council to ask Superintendent Dallas Dance to delay plans to convert all county high schools to an eight-period schedule is noteworthy for a number of reasons.

MASSACHUSETTS

New charter school still looking for location
South Coast Today, MA, February 25, 2014
City on a Hill Charter School, scheduled to open for 110 ninth-graders in August, will conduct its first admissions lottery next month without telling students or parents where the school will be located.

State eyes two charter schools
Boston Globe, MA, February 25, 2014
Massachusetts education officials are preparing to impose several conditions Tuesday on the operating licenses of two high-performing charter schools in Boston to ddress concerns about possible conflict of interest and to clear up any confusion over who is running the schools.

NEW HAMPSHIRE

Nashua Teachers Union criticizes Common Core standards test
Nashua Telegraph, NH, February 25, 2014
Nashua teachers are criticizing a new test being rolled out across the state next year as part of the transition to Common Core education standards.

NEW MEXICO

Charter schools a great option
Opinion, Albuquerque Journal, NM, February 25, 2014
On Feb. 3, the New Mexico Coalition for Charter Schools hosted the annual School Choice Fair, which included 35 independent, magnet and charter schools that provided information to over 700 families. The intent was not just to display the array of options the New Mexico educational system has to offer, but also to educate parents and students on the available possibilities.

NEW YORK

Charter co-location: A phantom threat
Opinion, New York Daily News, NY, February 25, 2014
A new study reveals that district schools sharing space with charters do no worse on achievement tests

City charter operators shifting advocacy efforts to Albany
Capital News York, NY, February 25, 2014
Operators of charter schools in New York City are looking to Albany for support after failing to gain traction on a series of core issues with local elected officials or the de Blasio administration.

‘Fail factory’ teachers & parents rip school’s principal
New York Post, NY, February 24, 2014
Teachers at troubled Murry Bergtraum HS on Sunday blasted its principal and p.r. guy for bungling a student letter-writing campaign to The Post — and one parent group said the school should be shut down.

NORTH CAROLINA

Mooneyham: Look at school choice
Opinion, Daily Reflector, NC, February 24, 2014
A decision by a Superior Court judge last week to block a new school voucher law was met with howls of disapproval from school choice advocates.

OHIO

State needs to focus on keeping students from dropping out, says Gov. John Kasich
Cleveland Plain Dealer, OH, February 24, 2014
Ohio has never had a clear focus on preventing kids from dropping out of high school, Gov. John Kasich said Monday, but it needs to now.

OKLAHOMA

Oklahoma bills to limit third-grade retention pass committee and head to full House
The Oklahoman, OK, February 25, 2014
Parents of students who fail a third-grade reading test would be given additional options to having their children held back under two bills approved Monday by the state House Education Committee.

PENNSYLVANIA

Rules at last
Editorial, Philadelphia Daily News, PA, February 25, 2014
REVIEWING the set of proposed policy changes from the School District that establish new ground rules for authorizing and overseeing charter schools in the city, we were struck with the troubling picture that emerges of the current situation.

Unions didn’t create school-funding mess
Opinion, Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, February 25, 2014
THE PHILADELPHIA School District is out of money. This is a fact. Now ask yourselves why. It is not because of teachers’ salaries and benefits. Philadelphia teachers do not have comparable compensation equal to their peers across the state.

Would-be charter school founder plans appeal of York City district’s denial
York Dispatch, PA, February 24, 2014
The would-be founder of a proposed York City charter school has decided to take her case to the next level.

TENNESSEE

Multiple charter school proposals clash with new MNPS guidelines
Tennessean, TN, February 24, 214
Metro school officials didn’t back down from a controversial new policy that defines where new charter schools in Davidson County can locate as talks opened on Monday.

VIRGINIA

Middleburg: County’s first charter school?
Loudoun Times, VA, February 24, 2014
For the last six months, three members of the Loudoun County School Board have been extensively sifting through the Middleburg Charter School’s application.

More time needed to decide how to grade Va. schools
Progress Index, VA, February 25, 2014
The House Education Committee approved a bill delaying the implementation of a new grading system for schools this past week, but some delegates are questioning if the new system meets the needs of Virginia schools, parents and communities.

WASHINGTON

Common ground on teacher evaluations needs common facts
News Tribune, WA, February 25, 2014
If the Legislature refuses, the federal government will definitely conclude that nearly every district in the state isn’t meeting annual yearly progress and will be labeled “failing.” That’s current federal law. After that, it is very likely that the Education Department will redirect $44 million in federal Title I money for high-poverty schools.

Senate’s schools funding disappoints Inslee
Seattle Times, WA, February 24, 2014
The state Senate on Monday released a proposed budget that would add money for public schools — but nowhere close to what Gov. Jay Inslee has requested.

WEST VIRGINIA

Teacher pay raise measure up for vote
Charleston Daily Mail, WV, February 25, 2014
Senate is expected to vote on legislation today that would increase pay for teachers and school service personnel.

WISCONSIN

Scrap Senate bill, not Common Core
Editorial, Green Bay Gazette, WI, February 24, 2014
A proposal in the state Senate would establish a board to set state academic standards, effectively ending the Common Core.

ONLINE LEARNING

Bill would alter payments for virtual Maine charter schools
Portland Press Herald, ME, February 25, 2014
A legislator says the state shouldn’t pay as much for online students because the true cost is likely lower.

Detroit’s EAA offers high school students flexible summer schedule
Detroit News, MI, February 24, 2014
Six high schools operated by the Education Achievement Authority will allow students to perform school work online at home and earn credit for internships during the summer as part of the district’s new trimester schedule.

Teachers use technology to ‘flip’ classrooms
LaGrange News, CA, February 24, 2014
Two teachers at Callaway High School have started using a teaching method that flips the classroom model of in-class lectures and homework by using lessons students can watch online, reserving class time to work problems.